
plate no. 5925
Winslow Homer, 1877
what to study here
It shows how a simple three-band value structure and a warm accent against cool distance can hold together a wide landscape with small figures.
The main lesson here is how value and temperature organize a big landscape around two small figures. The sky takes roughly half the canvas, with soft, blended cloud edges and brushwork that follows the cloud forms. Below it, layered mountains fade into atmospheric haze, and the vision notes say the distant ranges shift toward cool grey-blue while nearer slopes stay warmer. Squint and the structure reads in three bands: a dark base, mid-value landscape and figures, then a light sky. The darkest darks sit in the foreground vegetation, shadowed mountain sides, and the figures' pants. The figures' warm shirts are the main color accent against the cool mass, so they hold the eye first. Look at the edge control: crisper where mountains meet sky, softer inside the modeled forms. The foreground foliage is loose, with visible strokes and small white and red accents, and it only unifies at normal viewing distance. The figures are modeled with moderate precision, not photographic detail. Study how little finish the figures need to anchor the scale.
key decision
Homer keeps the figures' warm shirts as the one concentrated color accent against a cool, hazy landscape, and sets them on the dark foreground band so they read first.
recreation guide
Winslow Homer’s *The Two Guides* (1877) is a genre painting that reflects the artist’s post-Civil War transition toward scenes of childhood and domestic life, capturing a nostalgic view of simpler times (Source 4). As a work of Realism, it depicts ordinary figures engaged in common activities without attaching specific historical or portrait identities, aligning with the definition of genre art where subjects are perceived as types rather than individuals (Source 3). The painting likely employs the traditional oil painting methods Homer studied under Frederick Rondel and at the National Academy of Design, which emphasized sound craftsmanship and the mastery of medium capacities (Source 2, Source 4).
estimated time
20-30 hours over 5-7 sessions
materials
5 items
steps
4 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Oil paints (Black, Ultramarine, White, Red, Yellow) | Primary pigments for grisaille underpainting and subsequent glazing/scumbling layers. | — |
| Oil of Copavia (or modern damar/resin substitute) | Medium for the first and second paintings to ensure proper drying and transparency, as cited in Reynolds' method referenced by Homer's contemporaries. | Damar varnish or Galkyd |
| Linseed Oil | Standard binder for oil paint application. | — |
| Mineral Spirits/Turpentine | Solvent for thinning paint and cleaning brushes. | — |
| Canvas | Support surface. | — |
preparation
surface prep
Prepare a standard oil-primed canvas. While specific ground preparation for *The Two Guides* is not detailed in the sources, Homer’s training at the National Academy of Design and with Frederick Rondel would have instilled standard 19th-century academic practices for oil support preparation (Source 4).
underdrawing
Sketch the composition using charcoal or thinned paint. Traditional oil painting techniques often begin with this step to establish the design before applying paint (Source 8). Homer’s early work was based on sketches, indicating a reliance on preparatory drawing to capture the 'quiet moments' and figures accurately (Source 4).
underpainting
Create a monochrome underpainting (grisaille). Mentally extract red and yellow colors, painting only what would remain in nature if those colors were absent. This establishes the value structure. Use black, ultramarine, and white mixed with oil of copavia for the first and second paintings, as described in the method attributed to Sir Joshua Reynolds and noted as a practice of old masters (Source 1).
color palette
Black, Ultramarine, White
Pure pigments mixed with oil of copavia
Grisaille underpainting to establish values and forms.
Red and Yellow tones
Transparent red and yellow pigments
Glazing and scumbling layers to introduce color, mimicking the tinting of an engraving.
composition
The composition likely emphasizes broad masses and realistic depiction of ordinary figures, consistent with Homer’s genre painting style which avoids the 'smallness' or over-modeling associated with timid outlining (Source 2, Source 3). The figures are likely arranged to convey a narrative of everyday life without specific identity, focusing on the interaction between the subjects (Source 3).
step by step
underdrawing
step 01
Sketch the figures and setting onto the canvas using charcoal or thinned paint to establish the composition.
Tip — Ensure the proportions are accurate, as Homer’s realism relied on careful observation.
Traditional oil sketching
underpainting
step 02
Paint a grisaille using black, ultramarine, and white mixed with oil of copavia. Exclude red and yellow tones to establish the value structure.
Tip — Mentally extract red and yellow colors, translating what would be left in nature without them.
Monochrome underpainting
refining
step 03
Once the grisaille is quite dry, apply glazes and scumbles using oil (or varnish and oil mixed) to introduce red and yellow tones.
Tip — Apply colors much as you would tint an engraving with watercolors. Glazing is a transparent coat; scumbling is semi-opaque.
Glazing and Scumbling
finishing
step 04
Refine the details, ensuring that the underlying painting makes itself felt through the semi-opaque scumbles, particularly over darker grounds to achieve a grey bloom if desired.
Tip — Watch for coldness when scumbling over darker grounds; adjust transparency as needed.
Scumbling
critical techniques
Glazing and Scumbling
Used to apply red and yellow tones over a dry grisaille underpainting. Glazing provides transparent color, while scumbling provides semi-opaque layers that allow the underlying painting to show through, creating depth and texture.
Monochrome Underpainting
Establishing the painting’s values using only black, ultramarine, and white before introducing color. This method was practiced by old masters and is recommended for achieving mastery over the medium.
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
The Practice of Oil Painting↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia: Genre painting↗
Wikipedia bio — Winslow Homer↗
Wikipedia: Oil painting↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
Light enters from the upper left, creating bright cumulus clouds that dominate roughly half the canvas against a blue-green sky. Two figures in warm-colored shirts stand on a rocky, vegetation-scattered knoll in the foreground, anchoring the composition and drawing the eye first. Beyond them, a vast panorama of layered mountains recedes into atmospheric haze, with a pale valley visible in the middle distance. The eye travels upward from the figures to the sky, then horizontally across the mountain ranges, following the warm figures as the primary focal points against cool landscape mass.
value structure
The darkest darks cluster in the foreground vegetation, the shadowed sides of the mountains, and the figures' pants and shadows. The figures' warm-colored shirts and the illuminated mountain slopes occupy the middle value range. The brightest lights are the clouds and sky highlights, which occupy roughly half the composition and create atmospheric lift. When squinted, the structure reads clearly: dark band at the base, medium values in the middle landscape and figures, then a dominant light-filled sky above.
observed palette and mixes
#9da08a
ultramarine blue + burnt umber + titanium white
the shadowed sides of distant mountains and cool mid-tones throughout the landscape
#b7b49b
yellow ochre + titanium white + touch of ultramarine
the sky's cream-colored highlights within clouds and warm sky transitions
#75745e
burnt umber + ultramarine blue + yellow ochre
the foreground rocky ground, shadowed foliage, and muted vegetation
#443220
burnt umber + cadmium red + ultramarine blue
the darkest foliage shadows and the dark pants of both figures
#45402c
yellow ochre + burnt umber + ultramarine
the mid-tone foliage and the tan/khaki colored shirt of the right figure
#322d1d
burnt umber + ultramarine blue + cadmium red
the deepest shadows in the foreground and mountain silhouettes
edges and brushwork
The sky and clouds employ soft, blended edges with visible directional brushwork following the cloud forms. The distant mountains have crisper edges where they meet the sky but soften within their modeled forms. The foreground foliage is rendered loosely with visible individual strokes, creating a tapestry of small shapes—white flowers, red accents, green and brown masses—that read as unified only when viewed from normal distance. The figures themselves are painted with moderate precision showing form and anatomy, but without photographic detail.
a working sequence
Establish the composition underpainting
Using burnt umber thinned with solvent, block in the major shapes: the horizon line with the mountain ridge, the position of both figures, and the cloud masses. Keep this light and gestural. The mountains should read as a clear silhouette; the figures need enough definition to show their standing posture.
Build the sky foundation
Paint the entire sky area with its dominant pale blue-green base. Establish where the clouds will sit—note how they're concentrated in the upper-center and right portion. Use titanium white mixed with ultramarine and yellow ochre for the cream areas within clouds; add more ultramarine for the cooler blue zones. Keep edges soft and allow colors to blend while wet.
Model the mountain masses
Block in the mountains with their local value—they're notably darker than the sky but not black. The left mountain is darker and more defined; the distant mountains fade to grey-blue. Use ultramarine blue + burnt umber, varying the proportion to suggest atmospheric perspective. The sunlit slopes should have a warmer undertone (add yellow ochre). Leave clear separation between mountain form and sky.
Paint the figures and their values
Establish the rust-red shirt of the left figure (cadmium red + burnt umber) and the tan shirt of the right figure (yellow ochre + white). Their pants are dark (burnt umber + ultramarine). Block in their basic form and anatomy, paying attention to how the red shirt reads brightly against the cool landscape behind. Don't detail faces yet—focus on mass and silhouette.
Build the foreground vegetation and rocky ground
Layer in the complex foreground foliage with multiple warm and cool strokes. Use muted greens, ochres, reds, and browns—don't make them bright. Begin indicating white wildflowers and the red tree accent on the right. The rocky ground should show tan and grey tones with darker shadows. Work loosely here; individual brushstrokes should be visible but unified as a mass.
Refine sky clouds and atmospheric effects
Return to the sky and refine the cloud forms. The clouds nearest the figures' heads should have more definition than distant clouds. Build shadows in clouds with blue-grey (ultramarine + burnt umber) and highlights with warmer creams. Ensure the sky above the mountains gradually shifts from warmer cream near the horizon to cooler blue at the top.
Develop figure features and create focal emphasis
Refine the figures' heads, hands, and visible anatomy. The left figure's hat brim and the gesture of pointing should be clear. Keep the faces subtle and modeled rather than detailed. The red shirt should pop against the background—ensure this value relationship holds. The figures' positioning and pose direct the viewer's attention.
Final details and edge work
Add crisp edges where the figures meet the landscape. Define accent vegetation—the reddish tree on the right and scattered white flowers. Soften edges where mountains meet sky, particularly in distant zones. Step back frequently to check value relationships, especially the critical separation between the dark foreground and light sky. Make any final adjustments to ensure the dramatic atmospheric perspective reads clearly.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
in this vein