
plate no. 9509
Vladimir Makovsky, 1917
what to study here
It shows how a narrow warm value range, soft edges, and a few well-placed darks can hold a seated figure against a loosely suggested autumn park.
The useful lesson here is restraint in a mid-value, warm-dominated portrait. Most of the painting sits in a compressed mid-to-mid-light range, so the few real darks do the structural work: the top hat and the deep jacket folds anchor the figure. Squint and three masses remain: the figure, the bench, and a pale background. Study how the background trees are suggested with downward flicks in tan and muted green-brown, with mustard, rust, and ochre accents, rather than drawn leaf by leaf. Edges are soft and often lost where the figure meets the foliage and where the jacket drops into shadow, yet the jacket still carries clean directional strokes that describe form. The face is modeled gently in warm earth tones without sharp definition. The cream waistcoat and light shoes are the lightest accents, so they must stay muted to avoid competing with the figure. Look at how little is stated and how much still reads. The finish is painterly, not photographic.
key decision
The painter kept most of the picture in a compressed mid-value range and reserved the darkest values for the top hat and jacket folds. Background foliage is handled with loose, directional strokes and lost edges so the figure stays dominant.
recreation guide
This recreation guide addresses the painting of a realistic portrait on panel using oil paints, consistent with Vladimir Makovsky’s documented practice in Realism. The artwork depicts a man seated on a park bench, a composition that requires careful attention to the sitter’s posture and the naturalistic setting. Makovsky, working within the Realist tradition, would prioritize the truthful expression of the subject’s character and physical presence over idealized beauty, relying on the material vitality of oil paint to convey texture and light rather than attempting photographic deception (Source 1). The process emphasizes the structural integrity of the drawing and the harmonious use of color contrasts to define the figure against the background.
estimated time
20-30 hours over 5-7 sessions
materials
7 items
steps
5 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Wood panel | Support surface, consistent with historical panel painting traditions and the artwork's medium specification. | MDF or plywood panel primed with gesso |
| Oil paints | Primary medium, offering flexibility, rich color, and layering capabilities. | Tube oil paints (linseed or walnut oil base) |
| Raw Umber | For underpainting and setting the palette, as advised for initial studies. | Raw Umber pigment |
| White pigment (soft white) | For mixing tints and highlights, used in conjunction with raw umber. | Titanium White or Lead White (historical) |
| Turpentine | Thinner for initial layers and cleaning brushes. | Odorless mineral spirits or turpentine |
| Charcoal | For initial drawing and shading to establish proportions before painting. | Vine charcoal or compressed charcoal |
| Brushes | Various sizes for drawing, underpainting, and refining details. | Hog bristle and sable brushes |
preparation
surface prep
Prepare a wood panel surface. Historically, oil painting on wood panel was common before canvas became dominant (Source 2). Ensure the panel is sealed and primed to accept oil paints. Makovsky’s realism requires a smooth enough surface to render fine details of the face and clothing textures, but not so glossy as to prevent brushwork adhesion.
underdrawing
Begin with a charcoal drawing. Do not hesitate to hold your brush or charcoal against the model’s face to ascertain length and proportions (Source 3). Make the study slightly smaller than life size. Draw and shade in charcoal, using a dry brush to model forms if necessary. Place the drawing alongside the sitter, on a level with the face, and use a hand-mirror to compare the drawing with nature from a distance to check for proportional errors (Source 3). Make all corrections in the charcoal stage, as charcoal offers little resistance to correction, whereas correcting paint is fatal to lucidity (Source 3).
underpainting
Set the palette with raw umber and soft white, using turpentine to thin the paint (Source 3). Apply an initial layer of paint with the idea of going over it at least three or four times. This underpainting establishes the tonal values and composition before detailed color work begins. Avoid putting down paint with obvious errors in construction, as these are difficult to correct later (Source 3).
color palette
Raw Umber
Pure pigment thinned with turpentine
Underpainting and establishing dark values
Soft White
Highlights and mixing tints
Complexion Tones
Mixtures of red, yellow, and white, adjusted with complements
Skin tones, avoiding the error of using only red and white (Source 4)
Background/Dress Colors
Complementary colors to the complexion
Creating contrast and harmony, ensuring the dress and background enhance the face (Source 4)
composition
The sitter is seated on a park bench, a naturalistic setting. While specific details of the park are not described in the sources, the composition likely employs a three-quarter view, which is engaging and allows for a better view of the head’s shape and features (Source 8). The gaze may be detached or aloof, consistent with traditional portraiture, or engaged if the artist seeks to capture a specific emotional state (Source 8). The posture should reveal the sitter’s physical and emotional state (Source 5).
step by step
underdrawing
step 01
Draw the figure in charcoal, checking proportions by holding the brush against the model’s face and comparing the drawing to the sitter via a mirror.
Tip — Correct all errors in charcoal before applying paint.
Direct measurement and mirror comparison
underpainting
step 02
Apply a thin layer of raw umber and white mixed with turpentine to establish basic tones and forms.
Tip — Plan for multiple layers; do not finalize details in this stage.
Monochrome underpainting
first pass
step 03
Begin applying color, focusing on the predominant color of the complexion. Use complementary colors for the dress and background to create harmony and contrast.
Tip — Avoid using only red and white for skin tones; observe the true hues of the complexion.
Color harmony and contrast
refining
step 04
Build up layers of paint, refining details of the face, hair, and clothing. Use the plasticity of oil paint to create texture.
Tip — Remember that oil paint is a medium for expression, not just deception; maintain the vitality of the medium.
Layering and texturing
finishing
step 05
Finalize the painting, ensuring that the emotional idea of the sitter is expressed through the painted symbols.
Tip — Do not lose sight of the medium’s qualities in the pursuit of illusion.
Expressive realism
critical techniques
Mirror Comparison
Using a hand-mirror to compare the drawing with the sitter from a distance to detect proportional errors.
Color Contrast
Using complementary colors in the dress and background to enhance the complexion and avoid monotony.
Layering
Applying paint in multiple layers (at least three or four) to build depth and detail.
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
The Practice and Science of Drawing↗
The Practice of Oil Painting↗
Laws of Contrast of Colour↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia: Oil painting↗
Wikipedia: Portrait painting↗
Wikipedia: Early Netherlandish painting↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
A bearded man in a top hat and brown overcoat sits on a wooden bench, gazing downward with a contemplative pose. Soft afternoon light falls from the left-front, modeling his face and figure with warm tones against the diffuse, pale background. Behind him, autumn trees with scattered leaves in mustard, rust, and ochre create a hazy atmospheric setting—not sharply focused, but suggested through loose, directional brushwork. The bench is rendered in warm and cool earth tones, anchoring the composition horizontally. Scattered fallen leaves litter the sandy ground in the foreground, warming the base plane.
value structure
The darkest values concentrate in the top hat and the deep shadows of the jacket folds; the lightest values are the pale cream waistcoat, the background sky, and the light shoes. Most of the painting sits in a compressed mid-to-mid-light register—the face and exposed skin are warm, medium-value earth tones, not bright. The foliage in the background reads as a unified middle value with warm and cool variations within it. Squint and you see three dominant masses: the figure (darkish medium), the bench (medium-warm), and the background (light-to-medium pale).
observed palette and mixes
#967548
Yellow Ochre + Burnt Sienna + White
Warm tan highlights on the jacket sleeves, bench face, and ground
#3b2b1f
Mars Black + Burnt Umber
The top hat and deepest shadows in the jacket folds
#675136
Yellow Ochre + Ultramarine + Burnt Sienna
Muted greenish-brown foliage and jacket shadow planes
#825c32
Raw Sienna + Yellow Ochre
The bearded face, exposed neck, and mid-tone jacket areas
#bcad9d
Titanium White + Yellow Ochre + touch of Alizarin Crimson
The cream waistcoat, pale background sky, and light shoes
#a68d68
Burnt Sienna + Ultramarine + White
Warm gray-brown bench structure and cool foliage accents
edges and brushwork
Edges throughout are soft and often lost—particularly where the figure meets the background foliage and where the jacket transitions to shadow. The brushwork is visible and directional rather than blended smooth; the background trees are suggested with downward flicks of the brush in tan and muted green-browns rather than rendered literally. The face shows gentle modeling without sharp definition; the jacket displays clean directional strokes that describe form without slicking out the paint. This is painterly realism, not photographic finish.
a working sequence
Proportions and values block-in
Lay in a thin, warm-toned wash to establish the overall composition. Indicate the bench structure with simple geometric planes—top surface as a horizontal warm tan, front face as a darker cool-brown, and legs suggested with minimal marks. Place the figure's shoulders and head proportions, and note the downward gaze direction. Block in the three main value zones: the dark hat and jacket, the cream waistcoat, and the pale background.
Background foliage and atmosphere
Suggest the park setting behind the figure with loose, vertical brushstrokes in muted yellows, warm greens, and cool browns. Keep the background soft and atmospheric—avoid detail or hard edges. The foliage should recede and not compete with the figure. Scatter some warmer ochre and rust tones to hint at autumn leaves without overworking. Leave the background deliberately unfinished-looking; this isn't a landscape, it's a backdrop.
Establish the face with warm modeling
Build the face using warm earth tones: raw sienna and yellow ochre for the mid-tones, with touches of burnt sienna in the cheeks and beard. The shadow side of the face (his right) should be cooler (ultramarine mixed into the sienna) but still read as warm overall. Keep the face simplified—model the planes of the cheekbones and jaw without tiny details. The nose and eyes should be suggested rather than finely rendered.
Paint the jacket and clothing structure
Establish the brown-olive jacket with its full value range: pale warm highlights on the sleeves and torso, rich dark-brown shadows in the folds and underside. The yellow-cream waistcoat should read as distinctly lighter and warmer than the jacket, visible between the lapels and at the center front. Add the blue-purple necktie as a small, cool accent—not large, but clear. Keep the paint application loose and directional; use the brush to describe the fabric's form, not to render texture.
Hands and lap definition
Indicate the hands resting on the thighs with simplified forms in warm flesh tones—don't over-detail. The hands should read as convincing in proportion without anatomical precision. Suggest the dark blue trousers with firm strokes, and place the light-colored shoes at the bottom with small touches of pale cream or beige. These elements ground the seated pose.
The hat and facial features
Render the top hat in very dark tones (nearly black with warm undertones), with a slight sheen to indicate its material. Define the basic facial features: the eyes looking downward, the nose profile, and the beard line. Use a single soft stroke for the mouth rather than a painted line. The features should be integrated into the warm modeling already established, not added on top.
Ground plane and scattered leaves
The foreground ground plane should read as sandy or paved in warm tan, not grass. Scatter small dabs of rust, ochre, and orange across the ground to suggest fallen leaves—use the smallest touches and don't overwork. These leaf accents should feel random and loose, as if they fell naturally. Keep the ground simple; it's not the focus.
Integration and final adjustments
Step back and check the overall warmth—the entire painting should feel bathed in soft, autumn afternoon light. Warm up any cool passages that feel too isolated. Soften edges that read too sharp, especially where the figure meets the foliage. Verify that the value structure still reads when you squint: dark hat, medium figure, light waistcoat, pale background. A final glaze of warm ochre or sienna over selected areas can unify the palette if needed.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
in this vein