apprentice
artistsserieslearnchatartworkscommunity galleryblog
apprentice

deliberate practice for serious artists

writingsourcesmethodsaboutgalleryprivacyterms
built by reducibl.com
home·artworks·After the duel
After the duel by Cristiano Banti

plate no. 2766

After the duel

Cristiano Banti

oil, canvasRealismhistory paintingfiguresarchitectureinteriorarchwayshadowshistorical

what to study here

It shows how much narrative a painter can carry with a narrow dark value range, one bright opening, and figures kept deliberately unresolved.

Study how the painter builds the whole picture on a narrow band of deep, warm darks and lets one bright note do the work. The brightest value is the sun-struck stone in the archway, a pale warm tan. Nearly everything else sits between very dark brown and near-black. Squint and the scene reduces to three tones: a shadow mass at left, a slightly lighter floor zone, and one glowing rectangle of lit stone. The two cloaked figures at left are loosely brushed and their edges blur into the walls, so the eye completes them. The fallen form in the foreground sits in murky shadow and is only suggested. The lit stone gets a little more edge definition, but it stays rough. Brushstrokes follow the architectural planes and the drape of cloth, and the floor is dragged with dry, visible strokes. The red cloak is the only chromatic accent, kept muted. Copy the restraint: decide where the light goes, then leave the rest dark and unfinished.

key decision

The painter confined nearly the whole canvas to warm, deep darks and reserved the highest value for the sunlit archway, so the light shape carries the composition. The figures and the fallen form are kept loose and low in contrast.

recreation guide

Cristiano Banti’s 'After the Duel' is a history painting executed in oil on canvas, characterized by the Realist style. While specific visual details of the composition (such as the exact arrangement of figures or background elements) are not described in the provided sources, the work belongs to a genre where the artist has significant freedom in choosing draperies, ornaments, and backgrounds to harmonize with the inherent colors of the human figures (Source 1). The painting likely relies on the principles of simultaneous contrast to manage the interaction between flesh tones and surrounding colors, ensuring that the 'true gradation of light' is achieved through the juxtaposition of tones rather than isolated mixing (Source 1).

estimated time

40-60 hours over 8-12 sessions

materials

8 items

steps

6 in sequence

materials

itempurposemodern equivalent
Oil paints (pre-prepared tubes)Primary medium for color application—
Linseed oilMedium to mix with pigments; traditional binder—
TurpentineThinner for initial layers and cleaning—
Raw umberFor setting the palette and initial underpainting/shading—
White pigment (softer white)For mixing tints and highlights—
CharcoalFor initial drawing and shading before paint application—
CanvasSupport surface—
Brushes (various fibers)Application of paint; hog bristle for bold strokes, sable for detail—

preparation

surface prep

The canvas should be prepared to accept oil paint. While specific priming methods for Banti are not detailed in the sources, the general practice of the period involves ensuring the surface is suitable for the 'vast capacity of oil paint' to create illusion without merely tricking the eye (Source 6). The surface must be stable enough to allow for multiple layers, as 'one painting will not suffice to complete the study' (Source 2).

underdrawing

Begin with a charcoal drawing. Draw and shade in charcoal, using a dry brush to model forms if necessary. It is crucial to make all corrections in the charcoal stage, as charcoal offers little resistance to a brush and none to bread erasers. Do not put down paint with obvious errors in construction, as correcting in paint is 'fatal to lucidity' (Source 2). Hold the brush against the model (or reference) to ascertain proportions, keeping the study slightly smaller than life if working from a model (Source 2).

underpainting

Set the palette with raw umber and softer white, using turpentine. Apply an initial layer with the idea of going over it at least three or four times (Source 2). This underpainting establishes the tonal values and composition before introducing full color intensity.

color palette

Flesh tones

Varied based on model; likely mixed with white and umber

Human figures; in history painting, these are often at the choice of the painter but must be harmonized with draperies (Source 1)

Raw Umber

Pure pigment

Initial shading and setting the palette (Source 2)

White

Softer white

Highlights and mixing tints (Source 2)

Complementary Colors

Dependent on local colors (e.g., red/green, blue/orange)

Enhancing brilliance or softening tones through juxtaposition (Source 3)

composition

In history painting, the artist has the choice of draperies, ornaments, and background to harmonize with the inherent colors of the figures (Source 1). The composition should aim for 'great effects' from which 'many small ones resulted,' adhering to the principle that attention to color contrast laws produces spontaneous details (Source 1). The arrangement of colors should consider that when two colors are juxtaposed, each approaches the complement of the other, modifying their appearance (Source 3).

step by step

underdrawing→underpainting→first pass→refining→finishing

underdrawing

  1. step 01

    Draw the composition in charcoal on the canvas. Shade lightly to establish forms.

    Tip — Correct all errors now. Do not proceed to paint if the drawing is flawed.

    Charcoal underdrawing

underpainting

  1. step 02

    Mix raw umber and white with turpentine. Apply a thin wash to establish basic tonal values.

    Tip — Plan for multiple layers; do not try to finish in one pass.

    Monochrome underpainting

first pass

  1. step 03

    Begin applying local colors. Pay attention to the 'inherent' colors of the objects (flesh, hair) versus chosen colors (draperies, background).

    Tip — Remember that in history painting, you can choose drapery colors to harmonize with the flesh tones (Source 1).

    Local color application

refining

  1. step 04

    Adjust colors based on simultaneous contrast. If a color appears too pronounced, surround it with objects of the same color but more intense, or use complementary colors to enhance brilliance.

    Tip — Red beside blue verges on orange; blue beside red verges on green. Use this to modify the aspect of a color without changing the pigment (Source 3).

    Simultaneous contrast

  2. step 05

    Check tone gradations. Ensure that the juxtaposition of different tones produces chiaroscuro, where the highest tone is enfeebled and the lowest heightened at the line of juxtaposition.

    Tip — This creates a 'true gradation of light' spontaneously (Source 1).

    Chiaroscuro via contrast

finishing

  1. step 06

    Apply final layers. Use fine brushes (e.g., sable) for detail work on faces and hands, and broader brushes for draperies and backgrounds.

    Tip — Avoid 'meretricious attempt to deceive the eye'; keep the work as 'painted symbols' true to nature but expressive (Source 6).

    Layering and detailing

critical techniques

Simultaneous Contrast

Used to harmonize colors inherent to the model with chosen colors. Juxtaposing complementary colors increases brilliance; juxtaposing similar colors softens intensity (Source 3).

Chiaroscuro via Juxtaposition

Placing flat tints of different tones side-by-side to produce gradation of light, where the lighter band is enfeebled and the darker heightened at the boundary (Source 1).

Charcoal Correction

Making all structural corrections in charcoal before applying paint to preserve lucidity (Source 2).

common pitfalls

  • →Putting down paint with obvious errors in construction or drawing, which leads to 'perplexities' and loss of lucidity (Source 2).
  • →Ignoring simultaneous contrast, leading to colors that appear inaccurate or muddy because the eye sees the complementary of the previously viewed color (Source 7).
  • →Attempting to finish the painting in one session, whereas multiple layers (3-4 times) are necessary for depth and correction (Source 2).
  • →Over-modeling or being too tied to the outline, which can make the work appear small or timid (Source 5).

what the sources don't tell us

Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.

  • ·Specific visual details of 'After the Duel' (e.g., number of figures, specific clothing colors, background setting) are not provided in the sources.
  • ·Cristiano Banti's specific personal palette preferences beyond general Realist practices are not detailed.
  • ·The exact year of creation is not available, limiting precise period-specific material analysis.
  • ·Specific brush types preferred by Banti are not mentioned, though general oil painting brush types are described.

grounded in

The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.

  • Laws of Contrast of Colour↗

    • 6. Put beside each other two flat tints... — applied to Chiaroscuro and tone gradation techniques
    • 324. In all, or nearly all, compositions... — applied to Choice of drapery and background colors in history painting
    • 315. As to the advantages the painter will find in it... — applied to Perceiving modifications of light and color on the model
  • The Practice of Oil Painting↗

    • PAINTING FROM LIFE — applied to Underdrawing, charcoal correction, and layering strategy
  • The Science of Painting↗

    • 4. When two colours separated by more than two others... — applied to Simultaneous contrast and color modification
  • The Practice and Science of Drawing↗

    • XX MATERIALS — applied to Philosophy of oil paint as expressive medium rather than mere deception

Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.

read from the painting

observed from the image, not the label
6 dominant colors, measured

what the eye sees

A dramatic interior of a stone corridor bathed in warm light from the background archway—the eye is irresistibly drawn upward and inward to the bright opening. Two heavily cloaked figures occupy the shadowed foreground at left, their forms dark and loosely rendered against the massive stone walls. A slumped form on the floor (the duel's aftermath) sits in murky shadow where the light barely penetrates. The light streams in from upper right, creating a sharp divide between the brilliant lit stone and the enveloping darkness of the interior; this is a painting about *absence* of light as much as presence.

value structure

Extreme value separation: the brightest note is the sun-struck stone in the archway (a pale warm tan), while nearly everything else occupies a narrow band of deep darks from very dark brown to near-black. The figures and foreground floor sit in mid-dark values, barely separating from the walls. Squint and you'll see three tones: deep shadow mass on left, a slightly lighter floor zone, and one brilliant glowing rectangle of lit stone. The transition from shadow to light happens mostly in the foreground; the background is relatively flat in its brightness.

observed palette and mixes

  • #1c1517

    Ivory black + burnt umber in shadow areas

    Deepest wall shadows, silhouetted figures, upper left corner

  • #2b1c1a

    Burnt umber + ivory black, warm bias

    Interior wall surfaces in shadow, dark clothing folds

  • #43342b

    Raw sienna + ivory black

    Figure shadows, architectural recesses, softer dark areas

  • #614b3b

    Burnt umber + raw sienna

    Mid-tone wall planes, architectural modeling

  • #84644d

    Yellow ochre + raw sienna, small touch burnt umber

    Lit stone surfaces of the archway and interior walls where light falls

  • #a86050

    Alizarin crimson + yellow ochre + raw sienna

    The maroon-red cloak of the left figure

edges and brushwork

The handling is loose and atmospheric throughout—figures are suggested with broad, confident strokes rather than outlined precisely. Edges between the shadowed figures and the walls blur and lose definition; the eye completes them. The lit stone surfaces receive slightly more attention and edge definition, but still painterly and rough. Brushstrokes follow the planes of the architecture and the drape of cloth; there's no tentative layering—each stroke counts. The foreground floor is scumbled with dry, visible brushwork suggesting worn stone.

a working sequence

  1. 01

    Establish the dark underpaint

    Using burnt umber and ivory black (warm darks), block in the entire interior including walls, ceiling, and the shadowed figures. Work loosely and establish the dominant mass of darkness. Define the rough arch shape in the upper center-right where light will eventually break through.

  2. 02

    Paint the lit stone archway

    Switch to your lightest value—a mix of yellow ochre with raw sienna—and boldly paint the interior of the arch opening and the lit wall beyond. This is your focal point and brightest passage. Keep edges soft but decisive; let it glow against the surrounding darkness.

  3. 03

    Establish figure silhouettes

    With a medium-dark value (raw sienna + black), loosely indicate the two figures on the left side. The left figure wears a reddish cloak, the right one dark blue-black. Don't render details—suggest their mass and posture with a few decisive strokes. They should read as silhouettes emerging from shadow.

  4. 04

    Model the wall planes

    Using burnt umber and raw sienna mixes at different values, carve dimensional form into the visible wall surfaces. The wall facing the arch opening (right side) catches more light than the wall on the left. Vary your darks—don't make them uniform. Keep the handling loose and directional.

  5. 05

    Add the maroon accent

    With a mix of alizarin crimson + yellow ochre, warm up the drapery of the left figure. This note of color punctuates the composition. Keep it muted and integrated into shadow—this isn't a bright red, just a warm tonal variation.

  6. 06

    Suggest the fallen figure

    On the ground in the immediate foreground, loosely indicate the prone form with a few dark strokes. Don't render it precisely; the viewer should understand what it is from context, not from detailed description. This is the narrative weight of the scene.

  7. 07

    Develop the floor and foreground

    Scumble and drag burnt umber + raw sienna across the foreground stone, following the perspective lines toward the archway. Use visible, directional brushwork. Add cool dark accents where the floor catches some reflected light. This anchors the figures in space.

  8. 08

    Refine light and shadow relationships

    Step back and check your value contrast. The lit stone should sing against the surrounding darks. If the figures are reading as separate forms, add soft edge work where they meet shadow. Add any final warm ochre notes to the upper portions of the walls where light grazes them. Resist overworking; atmosphere comes from restraint.

where studies of this painting go wrong

  • Rendering the figures with too much precision—they must remain shadowed and suggested, almost abstract. Fight the urge to add detail.
  • Underestimating the dramatic value gap between the dark interior and the bright archway. Push that contrast further than feels comfortable.
  • Making the stone surfaces one flat tan. The lit areas have cooler shadows and warmer highlights; model them subtly.
  • Using cool, bluish blacks in shadow instead of warm, earthy darks. The palette is entirely warm—even the deepest shadows have ochre or sienna warmth.
  • Overpainting the loose brushwork until it becomes tight and rendered. This painting's power is in what it *doesn't* show.

measured difficulty

beginner friendliness
value contrast
palette complexity
compositional simplicity
brushwork visibility

tips & new artworks in your inbox

no spam — unsubscribe anytime.

or to save artworks, chat, and track progress

related guides

oil painting for beginners →how to learn by studying the masters →
chat about this artwork

in this vein

related artworks

Portrait of James Wright

Portrait of James Wright

Thomas Eakins

Portrait of a lady

Portrait of a lady

Karl Gussow

Sisters

Sisters

Émile Auguste Hublin

Catching Up on the News

Catching Up on the News

Eastman Johnson

At the porter's room

At the porter's room

Vladimir Makovsky

Flowers and Fruit

Flowers and Fruit

Henri Fantin-Latour

Valle de México desde el Molino del Rey

Valle de México desde el Molino del Rey

Jose Maria Velasco

Self-Portrait II

Self-Portrait II

Mihaly Munkacsy