
plate no. 9963
what to study here
It shows how sharp architectural edges and a two-family value structure can make heavy masonry arches read as deep, light-filled space.
Start with the value structure. The visionGuide describes two distinct value families: deep interior shadows in both arch openings and on the right-side masonry (about #292929–#444444), and sunlit stone in the mid-tones (#585858–#8f8f8f), with almost no middle gray between them. The brightest values sit in the sky seen through the left arch and on the upper cornice and frieze. Study how those darks make the arches read as deep voids and pull the eye first to the center-left arch, then to the right. Notice the edge control. Arch voussoirs, cornice lines and window openings are hard and precise, while ashlar blocks soften where shadow meets light or where the stone is weathered. Brushwork is described as economical, with broad strokes following the wall planes. Inscriptions and the tiny figures at ground level are suggested, not rendered. The figures give scale, and the bright sky gap gives depth. Copy the hierarchy: sharp, measured structure for the monumental forms, and summary treatment for incidental detail.
key decision
Piranesi separates the image into dark arch interiors and lit stone with almost no middle gray, then opens a bright sky gap behind the left arch to pull the eye back.
recreation guide
This artwork, titled 'Remains of a covered porch, or cryptoporticus, in a villa of Domitian five miles distant from Rome on the Via Frascati,' is attributed to Giovanni Battista Piranesi. While Piranesi is historically renowned for his etchings and aquatints depicting Roman ruins, this specific entry lists the medium as oil and the style as Neoclassicism. Consequently, the recreation instructions must adapt traditional oil painting techniques to achieve the architectural precision and atmospheric depth characteristic of Piranesi’s vision, even though his primary output was graphic. The work falls under the genre of cityscape or topographical view, which often depicts specific places with buildings prominently featured (Source 7). The distinctive quality of such a work lies in the coherent composition of wide views, where elements are arranged to create a harmonious setting, potentially balancing detailed architectural forms with atmospheric sky or ground elements (Source 7, Source 5).
estimated time
20-30 hours over 5-7 sessions
materials
7 items
steps
6 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Canvas or panel sized with casein paste | Provides a stable, white ground for oil application | Pre-primed linen canvas or acrylic-gessoed panel |
| Charcoal or thinned paint | For initial sketching of the architectural outline | Vine charcoal or diluted raw umber |
| Linseed oil | Medium to thin paint and ensure 'fat over lean' layering | Refined linseed oil |
| Mineral spirits or turpentine | Solvent for thinning initial layers and cleaning brushes | Odorless mineral spirits (OMS) |
| Oil paints (Black, Ultramarine, White, Yellow, Red tones) | For grisaille underpainting and subsequent glazing/scumbling | Artist-grade oil paints |
| Painting varnish | To seal watercolor sketches or as a medium for glazing | Dammar varnish or alkyd medium |
| Palette knives and brushes | Application and scraping of paint layers | Standard hog bristle and synthetic brushes, stainless steel knives |
preparation
surface prep
The surface should be prepared with a white ground, as a white palette and white sizing allow for correct judgment of color transparency and keep tones light (Source 3). If using canvas, it should be sized with casein paste or similar excellent size to ensure stability (Source 3). The surface must be impervious to oil to preserve the integrity of the paint film (Source 3).
underdrawing
Begin by sketching the subject onto the canvas using charcoal or thinned paint (Source 1). Given Piranesi’s architectural focus, precise outlining is crucial. If the sketch is done in watercolors on the sized canvas, apply an even coat of painting varnish over it before proceeding with oil; this varnish will soak into the sizing and allow oil painting to continue even before it is fully dry, a method attributed to Paul Veronese (Source 3).
underpainting
Employ a grisaille (monochrome) underpainting technique. Mentally extract red and yellow colors to establish the tonal structure using black, ultramarine, and white, mixed with oil of copavia or a similar medium (Source 2). This monochrome layer should be allowed to dry completely before applying color glazes (Source 2). This approach aligns with the 'fat over lean' rule, ensuring the initial lean layer dries properly before subsequent oil-rich layers are added (Source 1).
color palette
Black
Ivory black or Lamp black
Grisaille underpainting and deep shadows in architectural recesses
Ultramarine
Natural or synthetic ultramarine
Cool tones in the grisaille and atmospheric sky elements
White
Lead white or Titanium white
Highlights and mixing with ultramarine/black for grisaille
Yellow tones
Yellow ochre or raw sienna
Glazing and scumbling to introduce warmth and light, particularly in sunlit stone areas
Red tones
Vermilion or red ochre
Glazing to add depth and warmth to shadows and architectural details
composition
While specific visual details of this particular oil painting are not described in the sources, Piranesi’s work generally emphasizes architectural grandeur. Compositionally, avoid exact bisections of the picture space; instead, position the horizon line to emphasize either the sky or the ground, likely showing more ground if the focus is on the cryptoporticus structure (Source 5). Create a center of interest to prevent the work from becoming a mere pattern, and use detailed areas contrasted with 'rest' areas to guide the viewer’s eye (Source 5). Ensure no spaces between objects are identical to maintain visual interest (Source 5).
step by step
underdrawing
step 01
Sketch the architectural forms of the cryptoporticus and surrounding landscape using charcoal or thinned paint.
Tip — Ensure lines are precise to reflect Piranesi’s architectural style.
Initial Sketching
underpainting
step 02
Apply a grisaille layer using black, ultramarine, and white mixed with a lean medium (e.g., oil of copavia or mineral spirits).
Tip — Mentally exclude red and yellow to focus on tonal values.
Grisaille
first pass
step 03
Allow the grisaille to dry completely. Then, begin glazing with transparent coats of yellow and red tones using oil.
Tip — Apply thin, transparent layers to build up color depth without obscuring the underdrawing.
Glazing
refining
step 04
Use scumbling (semi-opaque painting) over darker grounds to create coldness or grey blooms, particularly in shadowed areas.
Tip — Observe how the underlying painting shows through the semi-opaque layer.
Scumbling
finishing
step 05
Adjust translucency, sheen, and density using additional media like cold wax or resins if needed, ensuring each layer contains more oil than the previous one.
Tip — Monitor drying times; oil paint dries by oxidation and may take up to two weeks to dry to the touch.
Fat over Lean
varnishing
step 06
Apply a final varnish to protect the painting and unify the sheen.
Tip — Ensure the painting is completely dry before varnishing to prevent cracking.
Varnishing
critical techniques
Fat over Lean
Each additional layer of paint must contain more oil than the layer below to prevent cracking and peeling. This is a basic rule of oil paint application.
Glazing
Applying transparent coats of color over a dry monochrome underpainting to build up luminosity and depth, similar to tinting an engraving with watercolors.
Scumbling
Using semi-opaque paint over darker grounds to create coldness or grey blooms, allowing the underlying layer to show through.
Simultaneous Contrast
Be aware that colors appear different when viewed next to complementary colors. Adjust tones to account for this visual phenomenon to ensure accurate color imitation.
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
The Practice of Oil Painting↗
The Science of Painting↗
Laws of Contrast of Colour↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia: Oil painting↗
Wikipedia: Composition (visual arts)↗
Wikipedia: Landscape painting↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
Light enters from the upper left, flooding the two massive barrel-vaulted arches and illuminating the stone faces of the Roman structure. The dominant masses are the monumental arch openings themselves—they read as deep voids that anchor the composition, pulling your eye straight into the center-left arch first, then the right. Tiny human figures at ground level beneath and between the arches provide scale and atmospheric depth; the sky visible through the far archway creates a bright pull backward. The composition is a study in volumetric Roman architecture receding into shadow.
value structure
The darks are concentrated in the deep interior shadows of both arches and the heavily shadowed right-side masonry (#292929–#444444). Mid-tones dominate the sun-struck stone surfaces and architectural details (#585858–#8f8f8f). The brightest lights appear in the sky opening behind the left arch and on the upper cornice and frieze elements (#e6e6e6–#cccccc). The overall effect reads as high contrast—strong shadow plays against golden-gray lit stone—with almost no middle gray; squint and you see two distinct value families separated by the arch openings.
observed palette and mixes
#292929
Ivory Black + Raw Umber, heavily weighted to black
Deep interior shadows within both arches, recessed niches, shadow cast by the top cornice, shadowed bases of structures
#444444
Ivory Black + Burnt Sienna + a touch of Raw Umber
Mid-shadow masonry on the right building face, interior arch shadows transitioning toward light, worn stone edges
#585858
Raw Umber + Burnt Sienna + Ivory Black in equal parts
Sunlit stone faces of both archways, the major wall planes catching light, weathered masonry texture
#8f8f8f
Raw Umber + Titanium White + touch of Burnt Sienna
Lighter-struck edges of stones, frieze and inscription band near the top, highlights on architectural moldings
#cccccc
Titanium White + Raw Umber + Ultramarine (cool gray), very white-heavy
Sky visible through the left arch opening, brightest parts of upper cornice, bright stone catching direct overhead light
#e6e6e6
Near-pure Titanium White with minimal tinting
The open sky beyond the left arch, the brightest highlights on the upper architectural trim and frieze
edges and brushwork
Piranesi uses hard, deliberate edges to define architectural boundaries—the arch voussoirs, cornice lines, and window openings are crisply rendered with ruled precision. Within the masonry itself, edges soften where shadow meets light and where weathering has broken the stone; the individual ashlar blocks dissolve slightly at their edges in mid-tone zones. Brushwork is economical—broad, directional strokes follow the planes of the walls, and fine detail (inscriptions, small figures) is suggested rather than rendered, creating visual hierarchy between the monumental forms and the incidental.
a working sequence
Establish the linear armature
Using a ruler and HB pencil, lightly block in the two barrel-vaulted arch openings—note their slightly different scale and position relative to the vertical edge. Lay down the horizon line implied by the sky opening (upper left), the major vertical planes of the right-side building, and the receding orthogonals that suggest depth. Keep this grid extremely light; you're building a perspective scaffold for the stone surfaces, not drawing the arches themselves.
Define the major value masses and arch interiors
Using a 2B pencil and broad, directional strokes, block in the deepest darks: the full interior of both arch vaults and the shadow side of the right building (these are your #292929–#444444 areas). Leave the sunlit stone faces of the arch openings, the frieze band, and upper cornice untouched. This creates immediate volumetric clarity—the arches read as receding voids rather than flat openings.
Establish the lit stone planes and mid-tones
With a 2B pencil, lay in the mid-tone wash (#585858) across all illuminated masonry—both the left and right arch faces, the major wall planes, and the upper portions of the structure. Use directional strokes that follow the horizontal banding of the ashlar blocks. Notice the frieze inscription band sits slightly lighter; hold back here. Allow the dark interior shadows to frame this mid-tone layer.
Model the stone blocks and architectural details
Using a 4B pencil (sharp), draw individual voussoir blocks within each arch, the horizontal bed lines of the masonry walls, and the molding profiles of the cornice. Keep lines crisp and measured along the arch curves; let lines soften and slightly blur in the shadowed zones. The inscription band above the left arch should show fine detail; the distant sky and right-side details can remain more summary. This is where the ruin reads as constructed rather than abstract.
Add the highlights and brighten the sky
Using a tortillon or blending stump with a 2B pencil (or erasing with a kneaded eraser on a light wash), create the brightest value (#e6e6e6–#cccccc) in the sky opening visible through the left arch. Work highlights along the upper cornice and frieze, the top edges of prominent arch voussoirs, and anywhere direct light strikes a raised molding. These should appear as thin, deliberate accents rather than broad planes—they anchor the light direction.
Render human figures and atmospheric depth
With a sharp 2B pencil, sketch in the tiny human figures scattered at ground level within and between the arches—they're purposefully small and shadowed, adding scale and loneliness. Don't detail their faces; suggest them with minimal marks. Push the atmospheric depth by softening edges slightly as you move back into the far opening, and by keeping the distant sky lighter but less detailed than the foreground masonry.
Deepen and refine shadow transitions
Return to the dark zones (arch interiors, right-side shadow) with a 4B pencil. Darken the very deepest recesses where two planes meet, creating crisp shadow lines. At the boundaries where shadow meets lit stone, soften the edge slightly with a tortillon so the transition reads as light wrapping around volume rather than a flat line. The interior arch shadows should feel genuinely cavernous, not flat.
Texture and weathering
With a sharp 2B or 4B pencil, add subtle surface texture to the sunlit stone faces—small irregular marks suggesting erosion, missing mortar, and age. Keep this restrained; a few marks per large ashlar block suffice. The frieze inscription should show a bit more detail and clarity. Where stone meets shadow, let the texture dissolve. A light fixative spray at the end will preserve the graphite and prevent smudging.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
in this vein

Portrait of Sculptor Jean-Antoine Houdon working at the bust of Voltaire
Marie-Gabrielle Capet

The Roman antiquities, t. 1, Plate XXXI. Temple of Antonius and Faustina.
Giovanni Battista Piranesi

Portrait of Louis d'Orleans
Franz Xaver Winterhalter

Rooftops in the shadows
Pierre-Henri de Valenciennes

The Schmadribach Falls
Joseph Anton Koch

A Scene from 'As You Like It' by William Shakespeare
William Hamilton

Portrait of Klementyna Ostrowska Née Sanguszko
Vincenzo Camuccini

Self-Portrait
Anton Raphael Mengs