
plate no. 9219
Paul Klee, 1925
what to study here
It shows how one saturated, high-value shape against a near-black field, with drawn line as a second language, can organize a whole composition.
The main lesson here is how little value range the painting needs. Close to 80% of the surface is near-black, and the large golden-yellow fish is the lightest light, so it reads first and holds the picture. Squint and the composition collapses to one glowing mass in darkness, with almost no middle gray between the extremes. Study how the central fish is handled differently from everything else. It has visible directional strokes that follow the body, with stippled or short hatched marks for surface, and orange and red-orange toward the dorsal fin and tail. The smaller fish in ruby-red, pale mauve and olive are simpler and looser, so they support the main figure instead of competing with it. The blue wavy lines and spiky plant forms sit in a narrow mid-tone band just above black. They look drawn rather than painted, closer to calligraphy or ink work, which gives the piece a mixed-media quality that fits the listed medium of oil, watercolor and paper. Edges stay crisp throughout. Copy the contrast of treatments: worked paint on the hero, quick line for the water.
key decision
Klee kept roughly 80% of the picture near-black and made the central goldfish the only true light, in saturated yellow and orange-red. Everything else is held to simple shapes or narrow mid-tone blue line.
recreation guide
Paul Klee’s *The Goldfish* (1925) emerges from his post-Tunisia period, where he sought to create compositions analogous to nature’s formative principles rather than imitating nature directly (Source 1). The work reflects his synthesis of draftsmanship and color, a breakthrough he achieved after realizing that 'Color and I are one' during his 1914 trip to Tunisia (Source 8). Klee’s approach in this era involved using colored rectangles and blocks as basic building blocks, akin to musical notes, to create color harmonies (Source 8). The medium—oil and watercolor on paper—allows for the transparency and layering characteristic of his watermedia experiments, where he often combined graphic signs with color to harmonize object and abstraction (Source 1).
estimated time
20-30 hours over 5-7 sessions
materials
5 items
steps
4 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| High-quality watercolor paper | Support for mixed media; Klee frequently worked on paper supports during this period. | 300gsm cold-pressed cotton watercolor paper |
| Watercolor paints | Primary medium for transparent layers and color experiments; Klee used watercolors to implement strong light and color stimuli (Source 1). | Professional grade tube watercolors |
| Oil paints | For opaque accents and structural definition, mixed with watercolor as indicated by the artwork's medium. | Standard tube oil paints |
| Gum arabic | Binder for watercolors; essential for holding pigment in suspension and allowing for the transparency Klee utilized (Source 3). | Pre-mixed in tube watercolors or available as liquid additive |
| Fine brushes and pens | For applying water-soluble media and creating the graphic signs and grid-like structures Klee employed (Source 1, Source 3). | Synthetic round brushes and fine-liner pens |
preparation
surface prep
Klee often worked directly on paper without heavy priming, allowing the tooth of the paper to interact with the watercolor. For mixed media (oil and watercolor), the paper should be sturdy enough to handle the weight of the oil without warping. No specific ground preparation is cited for this specific work, but Klee’s general practice involved using paper supports for his watermedia experiments (Source 1, Source 3).
underdrawing
Klee’s works from this period often feature graphic signs and grid-like structures that dissolve into colored harmony (Source 1). He likely began with a light underdrawing to establish the 'grid' or structural framework, consistent with his method of conveying scenery in a grid to create compositions analogous to nature (Source 1).
underpainting
Klee’s technique involved layering transparent watercolors to build up color harmony. He did not typically use a traditional opaque underpainting but rather built up layers of transparent color, sometimes incorporating opaque elements later (Source 1, Source 3).
color palette
Complementary pairs
Red-Green, Blue-Orange, Yellow-Purple
Klee frequently used complementary pairs to create contrast and visual tension, reflecting his musical approach to color harmony (Source 2, Source 8).
Transparent hues
Diluted watercolors
Creating the 'colored harmony' and allowing the paper’s white to contribute to the lightness, consistent with his watercolor practice (Source 1, Source 3).
Opaque accents
Oil paints or gouache
Defining specific graphic signs or objects, as Klee combined graphic elements with color (Source 1).
composition
Klee’s composition likely relies on a grid-like structure, as he conveyed scenery in a grid to dissolve it into colored harmony (Source 1). The use of colored rectangles and blocks as basic building blocks, akin to musical notes, is characteristic of his post-Tunisia work (Source 8). Specific details of *The Goldfish* are not described in the sources, so the composition should follow his general habit of combining graphic signs with color to create a harmony analogous to musical composition (Source 1, Source 8).
step by step
underdrawing
step 01
Lightly sketch a grid or structural framework on the paper, establishing the basic shapes and positions of the elements.
Tip — Keep lines light to allow for transparency in later layers.
Grid-based composition
first pass
step 02
Apply transparent watercolor washes to establish the base colors, using complementary pairs to create contrast and harmony.
Tip — Allow layers to dry completely before adding more to maintain clarity.
Transparent layering
refining
step 03
Add graphic signs and opaque accents using oil paints or gouache to define specific elements, such as the goldfish or background details.
Tip — Ensure the paper can handle the weight of the oil without warping.
Mixed media layering
finishing
step 04
Review the color harmony, adjusting any areas where the contrast or tension is not balanced, consistent with Klee’s musical approach to color.
Tip — Use complementary colors to neutralize or enhance specific hues as needed.
Color harmony adjustment
critical techniques
Grid-based composition
Klee used grids to dissolve scenery into colored harmony, creating compositions analogous to nature’s formative principles (Source 1).
Complementary color pairing
Klee frequently used complementary pairs to create visual tension and harmony, reflecting his musical approach to color (Source 2, Source 8).
Transparent layering
Klee used watercolors to build up transparent layers, allowing the paper’s white to contribute to the lightness and harmony (Source 3).
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia bio — Paul Klee — part 11↗
Wikipedia: Complementary colors — Complementary colors — part 1↗
Wikipedia: Watercolor painting — Watercolor painting — part 7↗
Wikipedia bio — Paul Klee — part 4↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
A nearly black background creates an aquarium-like void, within which a large golden-yellow goldfish occupies the horizontal center, its body luminous and dominant. Around this central figure, a constellation of smaller fish—ruby-red, pale mauve, and olive—scatter across the composition at various depths. Blue wavy linear marks throughout suggest water movement and current, while stylized aquatic plants with spiky, branching blue forms occupy the periphery. The eye lands first on the bright central fish because its warm, high-value yellow sings against the dark field.
value structure
An extremely compressed value range: nearly 80% of the composition is deep, near-black, creating a dramatic platform for the single bright element. The central goldfish is the lightest light, rendered in saturated yellows and orange-reds with red accents at the dorsal fin. The blue vegetation and wavy lines occupy a narrow mid-tone band just above black. When you squint, the composition reduces to a single glowing mass (the central fish) floating in darkness, with minimal middle gray to transition between extremes.
observed palette and mixes
#191b15
Prussian blue + burnt umber, or lamp black with a touch of ultramarine
Dominant background and overall underpainting
#FFD700
Cadmium yellow light mixed with a touch of cadmium orange
Central goldfish body and main luminous mass
#FF6347
Cadmium red or alizarin crimson mixed with cadmium orange
Dorsal fin, tail, and red-orange upper portions of the central fish; red accent fish throughout
#00CED1
Cerulean blue or prussian blue with a touch of ultramarine
Wavy water lines, aquatic vegetation, and linear marks suggesting current
#8B7BA8
Alizarin crimson mixed with ultramarine blue
The pale mauve fish on the left side
#5D6B4F
Prussian blue mixed with burnt sienna or raw sienna
The darker olive-toned fish in the lower right
edges and brushwork
The central goldfish shows energetic, visible brushwork: directional strokes follow the body's form, with textural marks (stippling or short hatched strokes) creating surface quality rather than smooth blending. The smaller fish are rendered more simply and loosely. The water lines are drawn rather than painted—confident linear marks in blue that read as calligraphy or ink work, giving the piece a mixed-media quality. Nowhere do edges soften or disappear; everything maintains a crisp, expressive presence.
a working sequence
Establish the dark foundation
Cover the entire support with a deep, nearly black tone (mix prussian blue with burnt umber or use lamp black). Work quickly and aim for an even, consistent value across the whole field—this dark background is the stage that makes everything else read. Don't worry about perfect uniformity; subtle variation will actually strengthen the work later.
Block in the central goldfish silhouette
Using bright cadmium yellow, lightly draw or block in the horizontal oval shape of the main fish's body in the center of the composition. Keep it loose—you're establishing placement and general proportion, not refining edges. Notice it sits slightly above center, with its head (smallest, rounded end) pointing right.
Paint the central fish's body and color transitions
Fill the central fish with cadmium yellow, then while still wet, introduce cadmium orange along the dorsal (top) edge and bleed it into warmer red-orange tones. The tail fin should read distinctly red. The belly stays yellower and lighter. Use visible, directional brushstrokes that follow the fish's form—don't smooth or blend these transitions into invisibility.
Add texture and surface marks to the central fish
Layer short, energetic directional strokes and small stippled marks across the body of the central fish to suggest scales and surface texture. Use a slightly darker yellow-orange or even dilute red for these marks. The goal is to break up the flatness of the yellow and create visual interest, not realistic detail.
Scatter the smaller fish
Paint the smaller fish throughout the composition: ruby-red or coral-red fish scattered in the upper areas and sides (roughly 3-4 of them), a pale mauve fish on the left side, and darker olive-brown fish in the lower right. Keep these shapes simple and loose—they're supporting players to the central goldfish. Don't make them too detailed or equally bright.
Draw the wavy blue water lines and vegetation
Using bright cerulean or prussian blue and a thin brush or pen, draw confident wavy horizontal lines throughout the dark background to suggest water movement and current. These lines should be visible and energetic, not timid. Add vertical spiky branching forms for seaweed and aquatic plants, clustering them at the margins and between fish.
Add bubble clusters and final accents
Introduce small, round bubble-like forms in blue scattered throughout the composition—these help unify the underwater environment. Add any final eye details to the fish (tiny circles or accents), and consider adding very subtle additional marks or dots to reinforce the sense of depth and activity in the water. Step back frequently to check the balance of bright yellow against the dark field.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
related guides
in this vein

Dolly Sisters
Kees van Dongen

Nude with Loaves
Jean Helion

My Father
Carlos Botelho

Helen
Chronis Botsoglou

The portrait painter in the country
Albin Egger-Lienz

Marketta on Lázeňská street, Prague
Maria Bozoky

Winter at the Entrepotdok, in Amsterdam city
Paul Werner

Old Woman with Masks (Theatre of Masks)
James Ensor