
plate no. 7043
Paul Klee, 1921
what to study here
It shows how temperature shifts, varied edges and a few sparse symbols can describe a garden within a narrow value range.
Study how a landscape is built from a flat, tilted grid of patches seen from above, with a narrow cyan sky band across the top fifth to set distance. Warm golds, ochres and yellows dominate, and values stay in a tight mid-tone band. Cool teal-green patches recede slightly against the warm ones, so the push and pull comes from temperature, not from light and dark. The only real darks are the small black spiky form at lower left and some linear marks. The lightest note is the white circle at center, which reads as a sun or moon and anchors the eye. Notice the two edge types: the grid divisions are crisp and architectural, while patch interiors are scrubbed, layered and unblended, with earlier marks showing through. Green crosses and rust cross-forms sit on top as drawn symbols, applied with sharper, more linear edges. They tell you it is a garden without turning the grid into a picture of one. Copy the restraint: a limited value range, with texture and temperature doing the work.
key decision
Klee kept values in a narrow mid-tone band and let warm gold patches against cool teal-green ones carry the spatial read. A few small darks and a white circle serve as anchors.
recreation guide
Paul Klee’s 'Southern gardens' (1921) is a landscape work executed in oil on paper, reflecting the artist’s transition into a more structured, geometric phase of Expressionism following his Bauhaus period. While the provided sources do not describe the specific visual content of this painting (such as specific flora or architectural elements), they establish the technical context of the medium. The work utilizes oil paint, which allows for the manipulation of transparency and opacity, a complexity noted in historical texts where water-colors and oils are discussed as styles including 'impastements, opacities, and transparencies' (Source 3). The use of paper as a support for oil is a distinctive choice, requiring careful preparation to prevent absorption and degradation, as paper sizing must be evenly distributed to avoid stains (Source 3).
estimated time
20-30 hours over 5-7 sessions
materials
6 items
steps
5 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Oil paints (tube) | Primary pigment medium | Professional grade oil paints in linseed oil |
| Oil painting paper | Support surface | Heavyweight, acid-free oil painting paper or paper prepared with gesso |
| Linseed oil | Medium to mix with pigments | Refined linseed oil |
| Brushes (various) | Application of paint | Hog bristle for bold strokes, sable for detail (Source 4) |
| Palette knife | Mixing paint and applying impasto | Standard metal palette knife |
| Solvent (turpentine or odorless mineral spirits) | Thinning paint and cleaning brushes | Odorless mineral spirits |
preparation
surface prep
Since the artwork is on paper, the surface must be prepared to withstand oil without degrading. Historical texts warn that paper sizing should be 'equally distributed in the paste and not put on the surface just at the last' to prevent the inside from becoming 'irregularly spongy' and causing stains (Source 3). For an oil-on-paper recreation, the paper should likely be primed with a thin layer of gesso or an oil-based ground to seal the fibers, preventing the oil from rotting the paper over time, consistent with the need for 'substantial' preservation methods mentioned in Source 3.
underdrawing
Klee often employed linear construction in his compositions. While specific preparatory methods for this piece are not detailed in the sources, oil painting traditionally involves applying paint 'over a sketched outline of their subject' (Source 4). The artist likely used a light graphite or charcoal sketch to establish the geometric forms characteristic of his 1921 style.
underpainting
Given the medium is oil, an underpainting (imprimatura) may have been used to establish tonal values. Source 3 notes that water-color styles include 'washes' where 'the paper is reserved for the lights,' but for oil, the artist might use a thin wash of diluted oil to set the background tones before building up opaque layers.
color palette
Earth tones and Greens
Ochres, Umbers, Viridian, Yellow Ochre
General use in landscape depiction; specific hues not detailed in sources
Complementary contrasts
Reds and Greens, or Blues and Oranges
Creating strong contrast, as complementary colors placed next to each other 'create a strong contrast' (Source 8)
composition
The sources do not describe the specific layout of 'Southern gardens.' However, Klee’s work from this period is known for geometric abstraction. General landscape painting principles note that 'sky is almost always included in the view' and elements are 'arranged into a coherent composition' (Source 7). The artist likely balanced the 'massing of light and shade' (Source 5) to create depth in the garden scene.
step by step
underdrawing
step 01
Sketch the geometric forms of the garden elements lightly on the prepared paper.
Tip — Keep lines light to avoid showing through thin oil layers.
Linear construction
underpainting
step 02
Apply a thin wash of diluted oil paint to establish background tones and sky.
Tip — Ensure the paper is sealed to prevent oil absorption.
Wash
first pass
step 03
Block in main color areas using flat brushes for broad swaths of color.
Tip — Use 'flat' brushes to apply broad swaths of color (Source 4).
Flat brush application
refining
step 04
Build depth by layering transparent or opaque colors over dried layers.
Tip — Transparent layers can 'build depth, modify hues, or create shadows' (Source 1, Source 2).
Layering/Glazing
finishing
step 05
Add fine details and textures using smaller brushes or palette knives.
Tip — Use 'round' brushes for detail work or palette knives for texture (Source 4).
Detail work/Impasto
critical techniques
Layering/Glazing
Applying transparent layers over dried paint to build depth and modify hues. This is a fundamental technique in fluid media, allowing underlying layers to remain visible (Source 1, Source 2).
Brush Selection
Using different brush types for different effects: hog bristles for bold strokes/impasto, and sable/fitch hair for smooth detail work (Source 4).
Color Contrast
Placing complementary colors next to each other to create strong visual contrast, a principle of color theory applicable to Expressionist palettes (Source 8).
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
The Science of Painting↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia: Oil painting↗
Wikipedia: Watercolor painting↗
Wikipedia: Complementary colors↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
A geometric garden viewed from above, rendered as an interlocking grid of angular patches in warm golds, ochres, and yellows punctuated by cool teal-greens. A bright cyan sky occupies the upper fifth, creating immediate atmospheric distance. The eye enters through the warm central zone and scans rhythmically across the grid; focus anchors on the bright orange rectangles in the upper-center and the white circular form at true center, which reads as a sun or moon. Plant symbols—green crosses and red/rust cross-forms—float across and within the grid as if vegetation markers, grounding the abstraction in garden logic.
value structure
The painting's values compress into a narrow mid-tone band: most patches cluster between light tan and deep gold with no blacks except for the small spiky form lower-left. The lightest values appear as white edges and the white circle; darkest greens and the central black spikes create minimal but strategic dark anchors. Squinting reveals that warm yellows dominate visually, cooler patches receding slightly—a subtle forward-back spatial read through value alone.
observed palette and mixes
#efdc91
Cadmium yellow light + white, or yellow ochre + white
Bright patches throughout the grid, especially right-center and lower sections; the most luminous passages
#e2c055
Yellow ochre + cadmium yellow, with touch of orange
Mid-tone golden-tan patches across the central grid, creating the warm base
#b4a547
Yellow ochre + raw sienna, touch of black for desaturation
Darker tan and muted ochre patches; aged, weathered areas with visible texture
#b97322
Burnt sienna + cadmium red, or raw sienna + orange
The two large orange rectangles (upper-center and left-center), rust cross-form lower-right
#8cc599
Viridian or phthalo green + yellow ochre + white; or green earth + white
Muted sage-green patches throughout the grid; cooler planted areas and the cross symbols
#7fd4d4
Cerulean or sky blue + viridian or turquoise (small amount)
The sky band at top; also muted teal-green patches in lower-left and center areas
#ffffff
Titanium white, possibly tinted with ochre or green for aged effect
The central circle (sun/moon), white patch edges, light triangular forms; creates punctuation across the composition
#000000
Ivory black or Mars black, possibly tinted with deep green
The spiky star form lower-left; linear marks defining patch boundaries and plant stems
edges and brushwork
Edges vary deliberately: the major grid lines read crisp and architectural, while patch interiors show vigorous, visible brushwork—dry scrubbing, layered marks, and weathering that suggest age and organic decay. The plant symbols have sharper, more linear edges applied last; the surface overall is tactile and unpolished, with scratches and overlapping strokes visible throughout. No blending; paint sits in distinct layers with the underpainting and earlier marks showing through.
a working sequence
Map the grid and sky
Lightly draw the geometric grid structure in pencil—the arrangement of rectangular patches that form the underlying armature. The patches range from roughly square to wide horizontal rectangles; don't overthink proportions, embrace the irregularity. Paint the sky band across the top in cyan (cerulean + turquoise), leaving a soft edge where it meets the grid below. Keep this area relatively smooth compared to what follows.
Block in warm and cool zones
Using loose, broad brushstrokes, block in the major color regions: golden yellows and ochres for roughly 60% of the grid, orange-rust accents in the two large rectangles (upper-center and left), and sage-green patches scattered throughout especially the right and lower sections. Don't aim for smooth coverage—let streaks and gaps show; this raw application becomes texture later. Leave gaps where white forms will sit.
Place the white shapes
Paint the central white circle (sun/moon) as a clean, bright form. Add white as broken patches and edges within the grid—triangular slivers and horizontal bars that separate warm zones and add luminosity. These whites should read as the lightest notes and anchor the eye at center.
Add plant and geometric symbols
Paint the stylized green crosses and plus-sign plant markers in a muted sage-green across the composition—upper-right, right-center, lower areas. Layer in the red/rust cross-forms, especially the large pyramid and cross lower-center and right-edge. Add the black spiky star-form in the lower-left corner. These linear, graphic elements sit atop the grid and should read as deliberate marks, not integrated into the texture.
Build texture and depth through layering
Return to the grid patches with smaller brushes. Dry-brush, scrub, and layer marks atop the base colors to suggest age, weathering, and soil texture. Use darker ochre or thinned black to add fine lines, cracks, and directional marks that suggest direction and material surface. Build up the lower-left where the spiky form sits with extra layering. The goal is to make each patch feel worn and inhabited.
Refine values and cool passages
Assess the overall value balance; this painting avoids extreme contrast, so avoid heavy darks. Punch up select patches with touches of cooler gray-green or teal to recede them visually, especially in the lower-right and center-left. These should feel like shaded or cooler soil patches. Ensure the whites read as intentional highlights, not accidents.
Define patch boundaries and final marks
With a thin liner and dark gray or black, reinforce select grid lines—not all, but enough to clarify the geometric structure. Add small linear marks, cross-hatching, and staccato details in texture areas to suggest vegetation or water. These final marks should feel sparse and considered, not chaotic—think of them as deliberate notations on a weathered surface rather than a uniform texture.
Step back and unify
View the work from a distance. The composition should read as a warm, earthy garden grid with cool plant markers floating across it. If any patch feels too isolated or bright, glaze lightly with ochre or dull it with a touch of its complementary color. The overall impression should be harmonious, aged, and gently abstracted—not chaotic.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
in this vein

Dolly Sisters
Kees van Dongen

Nude with Loaves
Jean Helion

My Father
Carlos Botelho

Helen
Chronis Botsoglou

The portrait painter in the country
Albin Egger-Lienz

Marketta on Lázeňská street, Prague
Maria Bozoky

Winter at the Entrepotdok, in Amsterdam city
Paul Werner

Old Woman with Masks (Theatre of Masks)
James Ensor