
plate no. 5477
Petros Malayan, 1973
what to study here
It shows how contrasting handling, rough dry brush below and defined domes above, plus a narrow gray palette, can organize a composition into clear value masses.
The useful lesson here is how a limited, near-neutral palette carries a building and a rough hillside without losing either. The vision analysis describes three clean value masses when squinting: a dark church silhouette, mid-tone terrain, and a light, uniform sky. Check that against the image first. Then look at how the foreground is handled. The rocks are painted with visible dry brush and gestural marks that suggest stone without describing individual pieces, and they run from the darkest values into the mid-tones, which keeps the lower area from going flat. The church has clearer edges but stays painterly, and the sky is the softest passage, with edges dissolving into atmosphere. Light comes from the upper left, so shadows fall on the right and lower faces of the domes and towers. The middle ground is softened and lightened, which puts distance between the rocky foreground and the church. Notice the olive-khaki cast in the rocks and middle distance, which is the one warm-green note in an otherwise gray-blue and umber picture. Paint is reported as built up light over dark and dark over light.
key decision
The painter separated the image into three value masses (dark church, mid-tone terrain, light sky) and gave each a different edge and texture treatment. Rough, gestural dry brush in the foreground contrasts with the clearer, geometric church and the soft sky.
recreation guide
Saghmosavank (1973) by Petros Malayan is an oil painting classified within the Expressionist style and the cityscape genre. As a cityscape, it depicts an urban landscape, potentially focusing on architectural forms and paved areas consistent with the definition of hardscapes or townscapes (Source 3). The work utilizes oil paint, a medium that allows for significant expressive capacity through the adjustment of translucency, sheen, and the density or 'body' of the paint (Source 1). The painting likely employs traditional oil painting techniques, beginning with a sketch and adhering to the 'fat over lean' rule to ensure structural integrity (Source 1). Given the Expressionist style, the artist may have utilized methods such as glazing and scumbling to manipulate color and texture, although modern painters sometimes hold prejudice against these older master techniques (Source 2). The composition likely avoids exact bisections and uses contrast between detailed areas and 'rest' areas to guide the viewer's eye, consistent with general principles of visual composition (Source 5).
estimated time
20-30 hours over 5-7 sessions (allowing for drying time between layers)
materials
7 items
steps
6 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Oil paints (artist grade) | Primary medium for color and texture | — |
| Linseed oil | Medium to thin paint and increase oil content for upper layers ('fat over lean') | Stand oil or refined linseed oil |
| Mineral spirits or turpentine | Solvent to thin paint for initial layers and clean brushes | Odorless mineral spirits |
| Canvas | Support surface | Primed linen or cotton canvas |
| Charcoal or thinned paint | Initial sketching of the subject | Vine charcoal or diluted oil paint |
| Palette knives and rags | Application and removal of paint layers | — |
| Cold wax or resins (optional) | Adjusting translucency and body of paint | Modeling paste or wax medium |
preparation
surface prep
The canvas should be primed to accept oil paint. While specific preparation for Malayan is not detailed in the sources, traditional oil painting often begins with a prepared surface to allow for proper adhesion and drying. The artist may have used a monochrome underpainting (grisaille) to establish values before applying color, a technique used by old masters to mentally extract red and yellow tones and translate what would be left in nature (Source 2).
underdrawing
The artist likely began by sketching the subject onto the canvas with charcoal or thinned paint (Source 1). This initial step establishes the composition and forms before paint application. For a cityscape, this would involve outlining the architectural elements and spatial relationships.
underpainting
A grisaille (monochrome underpainting) may have been used to establish the tonal structure. This technique involves painting in neutral tones (such as black, ultramarine, and white) to create a value study before adding color glazes (Source 2). This allows the artist to focus on form and light without the distraction of color.
color palette
Neutral Grays/Blacks
Black, Ultramarine, White
Establishing the grisaille underpainting and shadows
Red and Yellow Tones
Various red and yellow pigments
Glazing and scumbling over the dry grisaille to introduce color, as these tones were mentally extracted in the initial monochrome stage (Source 2)
Complementary Colors
Opposite hues on the color wheel
Darkening colors without shifting hue, by neutralizing with complements rather than adding black (Source 6)
composition
The composition likely features a center of interest to prevent the work from becoming a mere pattern (Source 5). The viewer's eye is guided around all elements before leading out of the picture (Source 5). Exact bisections of the picture space are avoided, and the prominent subject (likely the Saghmosavank monastery or city structures) is placed off-center, balanced by smaller satellite elements (Source 5). The horizon line is positioned to emphasize either the sky or the ground, rather than dividing the artwork in two equal parts (Source 5). Contrast between detailed areas and 'rest' areas aids the eye in focusing (Source 5).
step by step
underdrawing
step 01
Sketch the cityscape composition onto the canvas using charcoal or thinned paint.
Tip — Ensure the composition avoids exact bisections and places the main subject off-center.
Initial Sketch
underpainting
step 02
Apply a monochrome underpainting (grisaille) using black, ultramarine, and white to establish values and forms.
Tip — Mentally extract red and yellow colors, focusing on what remains in nature without them.
Grisaille
first pass
step 03
Once the grisaille is dry, begin applying color using glazing and scumbling techniques.
Tip — Use oil at first, then potentially varnish and oil mixed, to tint the engraving-like underpainting with watercolor-like transparency.
Glazing and Scumbling
refining
step 04
Build up layers of paint, ensuring each additional layer contains more oil than the layer below ('fat over lean').
Tip — If layers contain less oil, the painting will crack and peel. Use palette knives or rags to adjust texture and form.
Fat over Lean
step 05
Adjust color mixing by using complementary colors to darken hues without shifting them toward greenish or bluish tones.
Tip — Avoid adding black to yellows, oranges, or reds as it causes undesirable hue shifts.
Complementary Darkening
finishing
step 06
Allow the painting to dry by oxidation. Oil paint is usually dry to the touch within two weeks.
Tip — Do not rush the drying process; oil paint dries by oxidation, not evaporation.
Oxidation Drying
critical techniques
Fat over Lean
Each additional layer of paint should contain more oil than the layer below to allow proper drying and prevent cracking.
Glazing and Scumbling
Glazing applies a transparent coat of color, while scumbling applies a semi-opaque layer through which the underlying painting shows. Used to introduce red and yellow tones over a dry grisaille.
Complementary Color Mixing
Using opposite colors to darken a hue without shifting it, avoiding the use of black which can cause hue shifts in warm colors.
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
The Practice of Oil Painting↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia: Oil painting↗
Wikipedia: Landscape painting↗
Wikipedia: Composition (visual arts)↗
Wikipedia: Color theory↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
The Armenian church Saghmosavank commands the center-upper portion, its geometric domes and cylindrical forms sharply defined against a soft, hazy gray-blue sky. Light rakes from the upper left, creating strong shadows on the right and lower faces of the structures. The eye moves first to the large central dome, then down through the clustered smaller towers. Below, a rough stone foreground dominates with bold, gestural marks—raw rocky terrain that anchors the elevated building. The middle ground recedes with softened atmospheric tones, creating depth between the foreground tumble and the distant church.
value structure
The painting uses a moderate value range anchored by very dark shadows (deep grays and browns in the lower church walls and foreground rocks) and light highlights on the domed tops and sky. The sky is the lightest, most uniform value zone. When squinting, three distinct value masses separate cleanly: the dark church silhouette, the mid-tone terrain, and the light sky. The foreground rocks bridge the darkest and mid-tone ranges with vigorous variation, preventing flatness.
observed palette and mixes
#3e4043
Raw umber + Payne's gray, with minimal titanium white
Deep shadows on the church domes and lower structures; darkest rocks in the foreground
#7a7d72
Raw umber + Payne's gray + titanium white (roughly equal)
Mid-tone architectural surfaces, stone walls, middle-ground terrain
#878c83
Payne's gray + titanium white with a touch of raw umber for warmth
Lighter faces of domes, highlights on upper structures, mid-value sky tones
#6a6c5f
Raw umber + Payne's gray + touch of muted green or ochre for olive cast
The distinctive olive-khaki tones in the foreground rocks and middle distance terrain
#989d96
Titanium white + Payne's gray + minimal raw umber
Brightest sky passages, peaked dome highlights, pale stone details
edges and brushwork
The handling is uniformly expressive throughout, never tight or photographic. The foreground rocks display vigorous, visible dry brush—bold gestural marks that suggest form without describing detail. The church structures have clearer edge definition but remain painterly; the sky is softest, with edges that dissolve into atmosphere. Layering is evident: the artist worked light over dark and dark over light, creating a sense of built-up energy rather than smooth blending.
a working sequence
Establish the composition and value underpainting
Block in the major shapes using a #4 round and thin paint. Lightly sketch the horizon line roughly two-thirds up the canvas. Map the church silhouette in the center, the rocky foreground mass below, and the sky above. Use a very dilute mix of Payne's gray and raw umber to establish which areas are dark (church lower sections, foreground rocks) and which are light (sky, dome peaks). This step should feel loose and gestural—you're finding structure, not finishing surfaces.
Paint the sky
Cover the upper half with a soft, atmospheric gray-blue using your #8 flat brush. Mix Payne's gray + titanium white as your base, adding a tiny touch of blue if desired. Work horizontally, letting the paint be slightly thinner at the top (more distant) and slightly warmer (more raw umber) near the horizon. Do not blend excessively—a subtle variation from cooler at top to warmer at horizon is enough. Leave this loose; the sky should feel like atmosphere, not a detailed surface.
Build the church domes and structures
With your #8 flat, establish the main architectural forms using mid-tone mixes (raw umber + Payne's gray + white). Block in the large central dome first, then the smaller towers flanking it. Use straight, simplified strokes—the geometry is already complex; avoid fussiness. The right and bottom-facing surfaces should be noticeably darker than the top-left facing surfaces (where light hits). Don't detail windows or stonework yet; focus on the three-dimensional form of the domes and their relationship to the sky.
Establish the foreground rocks and terrain
This is where expressive brushwork takes over. Using your #4 round and the darker mixes (Payne's gray + raw umber), begin making bold, gestural marks in the foreground. Don't describe individual rocks; instead, suggest rough, tumbled stone with angular, overlapping strokes. Vary your mark direction and pressure. Include the muted olive-khaki tones (#6a6c5f) here—the rocks have a green-brown quality. The foreground should feel active and broken, contrasting with the more defined church above.
Refine middle distance and create depth
Soften and lighten the terrain between the foreground and church using mid-tone mixes. This middle zone should recede visually—use less texture, softer edges, and slightly lighter values than the foreground. Let some of this area be suggested rather than defined. You're creating atmospheric perspective; the church should feel elevated and distant from the foreground rocks, not sitting directly on top of them.
Deepen shadows and strengthen darks
Return to the shadowed portions of the church (lower walls, right-facing surfaces) and the darkest foreground rocks. Use nearly pure Payne's gray + raw umber (with minimal white) to create deep, convincing shadows. These darks anchor the value structure and make the lighter dome peaks read against the sky. Be bold with this step—don't timidly darken, commit to strong shadow passages.
Add highlights and refine dome geometry
With a #4 round and a mix of titanium white + touch of raw umber, paint the bright facets on the dome peaks and upper architectural surfaces. These highlights should follow the geometric planes of the domes—they're not scattered randomly but define the three-dimensional form. Keep them restrained; a few strong highlights read better than many weak ones. This step makes the church pop forward and clarifies its structure.
Final texture and expressive refinement
With a dry brush (minimal oil on the bristles), go back into the foreground rocks and middle ground with quick, confident marks. Dry brush with varied mixtures—some lighter, some darker—to create surface vitality. Step back frequently to assess. The goal is not polish but presence; the painting should feel alive and gestural throughout. Don't overwork the church or sky, but let the foreground remain energetic to the end.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
in this vein

Dolly Sisters
Kees van Dongen

Nude with Loaves
Jean Helion

My Father
Carlos Botelho

Helen
Chronis Botsoglou

The portrait painter in the country
Albin Egger-Lienz

Marketta on Lázeňská street, Prague
Maria Bozoky

Winter at the Entrepotdok, in Amsterdam city
Paul Werner

Old Woman with Masks (Theatre of Masks)
James Ensor