
plate no. 4638
Paul Klee, 1923
what to study here
It shows how a mostly black canvas can be organized with a few saturated accents, plus three clearly different edge and brush treatments.
Start with the value structure. The canvas splits into three zones: a near-black ground, pale forms (four vertical white striped shapes and the moon) at roughly 90% lightness, and a warm mid-range of reds, purples and yellow. The black occupies most of the canvas and acts as the stage. Study how the six or so yellow birds, small but pure and sharp-edged, are spread across that dark field so the eye keeps moving and the darkness doesn't take over. Then compare the edges. The white plant forms are built from visible vertical hatching, so form comes from directional marks rather than smooth modeling. The red undergrowth at the bottom and sides is softer, with horizontal smudging that lets warm color fade into the black. The lavender-purple sky is painted in broad horizontal strokes with visible brush drag, and it holds enough mid-tone weight to link the whites to the dark ground. Copy a small section of each edge type and notice how the change in handling signals what is near, what is a mark, and what is atmosphere.
key decision
Klee set pure, hard-edged yellow birds against a near-black ground, while softening the red undergrowth into the black. The yellow reads first and the darkness stays active rather than heavy.
recreation guide
Paul Klee’s *Landscape with Yellow Birds* (1923) emerges from his post-1914 breakthrough in color theory, where he sought to create compositions analogous to nature’s formative principles rather than imitating nature directly (Source 1). This work reflects his synthesis of draftsmanship and color, a style he developed after being inspired by the light of Tunisia and the theories of Robert Delaunay (Source 2). The painting likely exhibits Klee’s characteristic use of geometric forms, grid-like structures, and playful, hieroglyph-like symbols, such as the titular birds, which he began incorporating around 1918 as reflections of his surroundings and inner visions (Source 1, Source 3). The medium is oil, a material Klee frequently combined with other media or applied using varied techniques like glazing and impasto to achieve tonal mastery and a fragile, childlike quality (Source 3).
estimated time
20-30 hours over 5-7 sessions
materials
7 items
steps
6 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Oil paints | Primary medium for color application and layering. | — |
| Canvas or linen | Support surface; Klee used various supports including canvas, linen, and gauze. | Primed linen or cotton canvas |
| Linseed oil | Medium to thin paint and ensure 'fat over lean' layering for durability. | Refined linseed oil |
| Solvent (mineral spirits/turpentine) | For thinning initial layers and cleaning brushes. | Odorless mineral spirits |
| Charcoal or thinned paint | For initial sketching and underdrawing. | Vine charcoal or diluted oil paint |
| Palette knives | For scraping, mixing, or applying paint in impasto or textured areas. | Standard artist palette knives |
| Brushes (various sizes) | For detailed drawing, glazing, and broader color fields. | Hog bristle and synthetic brushes |
preparation
surface prep
Klee worked on a variety of supports including canvas, linen, and gauze (Source 3). For an oil painting, the surface should be primed with gesso to create a stable ground. While Klee sometimes used cardboard or wallpaper, a traditional oil recreation on canvas requires a rigid, primed surface to prevent cracking, adhering to the general rule that oil paint dries by oxidation and requires a stable film (Source 8).
underdrawing
Klee was a natural draftsman who often combined drawing with color (Source 3). The underdrawing should likely be executed in charcoal or thinned oil paint to establish the geometric forms, grid structures, and symbolic elements (like the birds) characteristic of his style (Source 3). He did not abandon the object entirely, so the drawing should retain recognizable forms even if abstracted (Source 1).
underpainting
Klee experimented with color extensively, often using blocks of color with limited overlap in earlier works (Source 2). For this oil work, a grisaille or monochrome underpainting could be used to establish tonal values before applying color glazes, a technique supported by general oil painting practices for building depth (Source 4). However, Klee also worked directly with bold colors, so a direct color approach is also consistent with his 'bold color' experiments (Source 2).
color palette
Yellow
Cadmium Yellow or Yellow Ochre
Likely used for the birds and highlights, reflecting Klee’s interest in bright, stimulating colors akin to the North African light (Source 1).
Blue
Ultramarine or Cobalt Blue
Sky or background elements, often used in complementary pairs with orange/yellow to create harmony (Source 2).
Green
Viridian or Sap Green
Landscape elements, consistent with his vegetal shapes and garden scenes (Source 1).
Black/Gray
Ivory Black or Neutral Tint
Defining lines, grid structures, and creating contrast, as Klee often used graphical signs and dark outlines (Source 1, Source 3).
White
Titanium White
Highlighting and mixing to create pale watercolor-like effects or scumbling (Source 2, Source 4).
composition
Klee often used geometric forms and grid format compositions to dissolve scenery into colored harmony (Source 1, Source 3). The landscape likely features a structured, perhaps grid-like arrangement rather than a realistic perspective, aiming for an abstraction analogous to nature’s formative principles (Source 1). The inclusion of birds suggests a playful, symbolic element integrated into the landscape, possibly reflecting his 'hieroglyph-like symbols' (Source 3).
step by step
underdrawing
step 01
Sketch the composition using charcoal or thinned paint, focusing on geometric forms, grid structures, and the placement of the birds.
Tip — Ensure the forms are recognizable but abstracted, avoiding strict realism.
Draftsmanship
underpainting
step 02
Apply a thin layer of paint to establish tonal values and basic color blocks. Use limited overlap to create distinct areas of color.
Tip — Keep layers lean (less oil) to allow proper drying for subsequent layers.
Block color application
first pass
step 03
Build up color using glazing techniques. Apply transparent coats of color to create depth and harmony, akin to tinting an engraving.
Tip — Allow each layer to dry completely before applying the next to prevent cracking.
Glazing
refining
step 04
Add details such as the birds and graphical signs using impasto or thicker paint for emphasis. Use palette knives for texture if desired.
Tip — Balance the fragile, childlike quality with structural integrity.
Impasto/Knife application
finishing
step 05
Review the color harmony, ensuring complementary pairs or dissonant colors are used effectively to create musical-like resonance.
Tip — Check for simultaneous contrast effects to enhance vibrancy.
Color harmony
varnishing
step 06
Apply a final varnish to protect the painting and unify the surface sheen.
Tip — Ensure the painting is fully dry (oxidized) before varnishing.
Varnishing
critical techniques
Glazing
Klee used glazing to create transparent layers of color, enhancing depth and harmony. This technique allows for the 'colored harmony' he sought to achieve.
Grid Composition
Klee often conveyed scenery in a grid to dissolve it into colored harmony, reflecting his abstract approach to landscape.
Symbolic Integration
Incorporating playful figures like birds and hieroglyph-like symbols into the landscape, blending object and abstraction.
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
The Practice of Oil Painting — COLOURING A MONOCHROME↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia bio — Paul Klee — part 11↗
Wikipedia bio — Paul Klee — part 4↗
Wikipedia bio — Paul Klee — part 8↗
Wikipedia: Oil painting — Oil painting — part 2↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
A nocturnal garden unfolds against an almost-black background, dominated by four vertical white striped forms that read as stylized trees or plant stems. The eye travels upward to the pale moon and purple-lavender striped sky, then moves laterally across at least six bright yellow birds scattered throughout the composition—their consistent golden hue creating a visual rhythm that prevents the darkness from overwhelming the piece. The foreground erupts with dense red-burgundy organic masses at the bottom and sides, while green, blue, and darker purple plant-like forms suggest undergrowth. The yellow birds, though small, anchor the composition because of their intense color isolation against the dark surround.
value structure
The painting operates in three distinct value zones: nearly black negative space (middle), brilliant whites (the four vertical forms and moon), and a rich mid-to-warm range (the red, purple, and yellow elements). The lightest passages (white striped plants and moon) sit at roughly 90% lightness, dropping sharply to perhaps 15-20% in the background, with the birds and plant masses occupying the 50-70% range. Squinting reveals the purple sky actually holds surprising mid-tone weight that bridges the bright whites and the dark ground, preventing harsh separation.
observed palette and mixes
#d7d4ca
Titanium White with minimal Ultramarine—keep it warm and off-white
The four vertical striped plant forms and the moon; adds luminosity without harshness
#454646
Mars Black or Ivory Black with a touch of Alizarin Crimson to warm it
The dominant background; the majority of the canvas—establishes the nocturnal mood
ffff00 (bright yellow)
Cadmium Yellow Medium or Cadmium Yellow Light, pure and undiluted
All six yellow birds—their saturation and brightness makes them sing against the dark
#986c65
Alizarin Crimson + Cadmium Red + touch of Mars Black for the deep rust-reds
The undergrowth masses at bottom and both sides; warm, dense, earthy reds
#8b4a6b (purple-wine)
Alizarin Crimson + Ultramarine Blue, bias towards red for warmth
The larger plant forms and some foliage—balance between the reds and cooler zones
#9b8b6b (lavender-gray sky)
Titanium White + Ultramarine Blue + touch of Alizarin—very desaturated
The horizontal striped sky at the top; creates atmospheric distance without cold harshness
#4a7c3a (muted green)
Viridian or Cadmium Green + Alizarin Crimson to mute, bias towards yellow-green
The vertical striped green plant forms; slightly muted to sit in the composition rather than jump forward
edges and brushwork
The white vertical plant forms show deliberate linear hatching—visible vertical striations suggesting controlled, directional brushwork building form through marks rather than smooth modeling. The yellow birds have clean, readable edges with minimal soft transition, allowing their shapes to register instantly. In contrast, the red undergrowth uses softer blending where warm tones blur into the black background, creating atmospheric recession; you can see horizontal smudging and layering here. The purple sky is painted in broad, gestural strokes running horizontally, with visible drag marks from the brush.
a working sequence
Establish the black ground
Fill the entire canvas with your darkened black (Black + touch of Alizarin Crimson). This is your foundation and will take longer than you expect—use a large flat brush and work in sections. Don't worry about evenness; subtle variation actually helps.
Paint the sky band
At the top, block in the horizontal purple-lavender stripe using broad horizontal strokes. Mix a desaturated purple (white + ultramarine + hint of alizarin). Leave your brushstrokes slightly visible—this is not a smooth gradient. The stripe should occupy roughly the top quarter.
Establish the four white plant forms
Block in the four tall white vertical forms with warm white (white + tiny touch of ultramarine to cool, but not much). Use a medium flat brush and paint them as simple vertical shapes first. Don't add striping yet—just the basic structure. Notice they're not perfectly centered or uniform in width.
Add linear hatching to the white plants
Using a thin round brush and dark gray or black, draw vertical lines across each white form to create the striped texture. Space them irregularly—some closer, some wider apart. This should feel like deliberate mark-making, not mechanical. The hatching adds visual interest and prevents the whites from feeling flat.
Paint the yellow birds
Using bright undiluted Cadmium Yellow and a small round brush, place your birds. You'll need at least six scattered throughout—roughly two in the upper zone near or perching on plants, two at mid-level, and two lower in the undergrowth. Keep each bird simple and readable; they need just enough detail to register as birds (small body, beak, legs). Vary their heights and the direction they face to create rhythm.
Build the undergrowth base layer
Mix a warm, muted red (Alizarin + Cadmium Red + touch of black) and block in the dense masses at the bottom and both edges. These should feel like tangled vegetation. Use a medium flat brush and work with a slightly thicker paint consistency. Let some edges blur slightly into the black, but keep distinct forms readable. Don't overblend—organic shapes benefit from looser handling here.
Introduce green and purple plant forms
Within and throughout the undergrowth and middle ground, add darker green striped or linear plant forms (muted green + touch of alizarin to keep it from screaming). Paint some vertical striations similar to the white plants but much smaller. Add dark purple-wine plant shapes in the spaces between—these should feel like stylized foliage rather than realistic rendering. Keep shapes bold and semi-geometric.
Add the moon and final refinements
Paint a simple pale moon shape (warm white, slightly off-center in the upper zone). Add any final details: small blue accent shapes in the foliage, white line accents where a plant edge catches light, refine any bird shapes that need sharpening. Step back frequently. The painting should read clearly from a distance, with the yellow birds and white plants as your strongest focal points.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
in this vein

Dolly Sisters
Kees van Dongen

Nude with Loaves
Jean Helion

My Father
Carlos Botelho

Helen
Chronis Botsoglou

The portrait painter in the country
Albin Egger-Lienz

Marketta on Lázeňská street, Prague
Maria Bozoky

Winter at the Entrepotdok, in Amsterdam city
Paul Werner

Old Woman with Masks (Theatre of Masks)
James Ensor