
plate no. 9195
David Burliuk, 1954
what to study here
It shows how three clear value zones and varied edges can organize a loosely painted flower still life against a bright window.
Look at how the picture divides into three value zones. The darkest values sit on the left: the vase interior, the shadow under the flowers, the portrait book and the apples. The lightest values sit center-right, in the white daisy petals and the window panes. Mid-tones fill the rest, in a muted blue-green wall, a tan vase and greyed foliage. Squint and the three masses should read before any detail does. Then study the edges. The vase has harder edges where it meets the bright window, while shadow edges on the left dissolve into the dark. Petals are soft where color drops into shadow and crisp only where light hits directly. Foliage is built from green strokes laid over one another without blending, and the flower cluster carries visible impasto. Notice also that the window divides the space: cool greens and blues outside on the right, the close still life on the left. Copy the value plan and the edge handling first, and leave botanical accuracy aside.
key decision
Burliuk set the darkest values on the left and the lightest in the center-right flower cluster and window. The daisies become the focal point through contrast.
recreation guide
This recreation guide addresses David Burliuk’s 1954 oil painting 'Vase with flowers and book by the window,' a work situated within the Post-Impressionist style. While the specific visual inventory of this particular canvas (the exact species of flowers, the book’s title, or the window’s architecture) is not detailed in the provided sources, the artwork belongs to the genre of flower painting. Historically, such works often prioritize compositional harmony and color contrast over strict botanical realism, sometimes combining blooms from different seasons to achieve aesthetic balance rather than naturalistic accuracy (Source 8). Burliuk’s approach likely emphasizes the 'laws of contrast of colour,' where the artist perceives and imitates the modifications of light on the model, ensuring that colors are harmonized according to their inherent nature and their interaction with contiguous hues (Source 1).
estimated time
20-30 hours over 5-7 sessions
materials
6 items
steps
5 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Oil paints (Raw Umber, White, plus a full spectrum of chromatic pigments) | Raw umber and white are specified for setting the palette and initial modeling; full spectrum allows for complementary contrast. | Standard tube oils |
| Canvas | Support for the oil medium. | Linen or cotton canvas, primed |
| Turpentine | Thinner for initial layers and cleaning brushes. | Odorless mineral spirits or turpentine |
| Charcoal | For initial drawing and shading, allowing for easy correction before paint application. | Vine charcoal or compressed charcoal |
| Dry brush | To model forms in the charcoal stage without smudging excessively. | Stiff bristle brush |
| Hand-glass (small mirror) | To compare the drawing with the model from a distance, ensuring correct scale and proportion. | Small hand mirror |
preparation
surface prep
The canvas should be prepared with a ground suitable for oil painting. While specific priming methods for Burliuk in 1954 are not detailed in the sources, standard practice for oil painting involves a stable, absorbent ground. The sources emphasize the importance of the support being ready for charcoal work, which offers 'little resistance to a brush' (Source 2).
underdrawing
Begin by drawing and shading in charcoal. Use a dry brush to model the forms lightly. It is critical to make all corrections in this stage, as charcoal is easily removed with bread or erasers. Do not proceed to paint if there are 'obvious errors in construction or drawing,' as correcting in paint is 'fatal to lucidity' (Source 2). Place the drawing alongside the model (or reference) at eye level and use a hand-glass to compare proportions from a distance, ensuring the study is slightly smaller than life if desired (Source 2).
underpainting
Set the palette with raw umber and the softer white, using turpentine. Apply an initial layer with the intention of going over it at least three or four times. This approach allows for building up tone and color gradually, avoiding the pitfalls of trying to complete the study in one pass (Source 2).
color palette
Raw Umber
Pure pigment
Setting the initial palette and establishing tonal values in the underpainting stage.
White (Softer)
Pure pigment
Mixing with raw umber for initial modeling and lightening tones.
Complementary Pairs (e.g., Red-Green, Blue-Orange, Yellow-Purple)
Varying based on specific flower hues
Creating strong contrast and vibrancy. When placed next to each other, highly chromatic complementary colors create strong contrast, enhancing the visual impact of the flowers against the background or vase.
Neutral Grays/Browns
Mixing complements or adding black/white carefully
Darkening colors without shifting hue undesirably. Mixing complements neutralizes color without the hue shift that adding black can cause (e.g., yellow shifting greenish).
composition
The composition should focus on the arrangement of lines and spaces rather than mere botanical correctness. The main lines should cut the space effectively, creating an irregular pattern where all lines and areas are related to one another (Source 5). Avoid disconnected groups or a small spray in the middle of a large empty space; instead, aim for a 'beautiful whole' where the floral lines form a coherent scheme (Source 5). The artist should distinguish between colors inherent to the model (the flowers, vase, book) and those chosen for the background, using the latter to harmonize the composition (Source 3).
step by step
underdrawing
step 01
Draw the vase, flowers, and book in charcoal. Shade lightly to establish form.
Tip — Use a hand-glass to check proportions from a distance. Correct all errors now.
Charcoal sketching
underpainting
step 02
Mix raw umber and white with turpentine. Apply a thin wash to establish basic tonal values.
Tip — Plan for multiple layers; do not try to finish in one go.
Imprimatura/Underpainting
first pass
step 03
Begin applying color, focusing on the inherent colors of the objects. Observe how contiguous colors affect each other due to simultaneous contrast.
Tip — Be aware that the eye may see colors inaccurately due to mixed contrast from previously viewed hues.
Simultaneous Contrast
refining
step 04
Enhance contrasts by placing complementary colors near each other to increase vibrancy. Darken shadows by mixing complements rather than just adding black, to avoid hue shifts.
Tip — Check for hue shifts when lightening with white; correct with adjacent colors if necessary.
Complementary Mixing
finishing
step 05
Review the composition for line harmony. Ensure the 'main lines' cut the space effectively and that the arrangement feels like a unified pattern rather than a disjointed collection of objects.
Tip — Step back frequently to assess the overall effect of light and color modifications.
Compositional Harmony
critical techniques
Simultaneous Contrast
The artist must perceive that colors appear different when placed next to each other than when viewed separately. The lightest tone is lowered and the darkest heightened by juxtaposition. This requires the painter to appreciate the color peculiar to each part and the modifications received from contiguous colors (Source 1).
Mixed Contrast Awareness
The painter must be aware that after looking at one color, the eye tends to see its complementary. This can lead to inaccurate perception of subsequent colors. The artist should rest their eyes or be mindful of this 'modifying influence' to ensure accurate color representation (Source 1).
Complementary Darkening
Instead of adding black to darken a color (which can shift the hue, e.g., yellow to green), mix the color with its complement. This neutralizes and darkens the color without an undesirable hue shift (Source 6).
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
Laws of Contrast of Colour↗
The Practice of Oil Painting↗
Composition — FLOWER COMPOSITIONS TWO VALUES↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia: Complementary colors↗
Wikipedia: Color theory↗
Wikipedia: Dutch Golden Age painting↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
Light streams from the right window, striking the vase of mixed flowers as the composition's brightest focal point. Your eye enters through the white daisies and pink/purple blooms clustered at center, then moves left to the shadowed book with its portrait and the apples in deep shadow. The vertical window frame divides the composition—cool outdoor greens and blues visible through glass on the right, while the left side holds the intimate still life. The flowers create a lively vertical accent rising from a stocky ceramic vase, with loose foliage suggesting movement and depth.
value structure
The darkest values anchor the left side: the vase interior, deep shadow beneath the flowers, the portrait book, and the apples. The lightest values concentrate in the center-right: the white daisy petals and bright window panes become your value landmarks. Mid-tones dominate the composition—the muted blue-green wall, tan vase body, and greyed foliage create breathing room between extremes. When you squint, three clear zones emerge: a dark left shadow mass, a bright central flower cluster, and luminous right window.
observed palette and mixes
#c8d2c1
Lead white with touch of raw umber
Window panes, brightest daisy petals, highlights on white flowers
#a7bfb8
Cerulean blue + lead white + touch of yellow ochre
Lighter wall area, cooler passages in background, outer window frame
#91a096
Viridian + raw umber + lead white
Muted background wall, foliage mass, shadowed greens
#597579
Ultramarine + yellow ochre + lead white
Medium wall tones, shadowed areas of vase, cooler mid-tones
#7b7d77
Raw umber + ultramarine + lead white
Vase body, table surface, brown shadows
#4b5254
Ultramarine + burnt umber + ivory black
Vase interior darkest shadows, deepest shadow beneath flowers, portrait definition
edges and brushwork
This painting lives in loose, gestural strokes typical of Post-Impressionism—the flowers are suggested rather than rendered with precision. You'll see visible brushwork throughout, especially in the foliage where green strokes sit atop one another without blending. Flower petals have soft edges where colors blend into shadow but retain crisp highlights where light hits directly. The vase shows harder structural edges at its silhouette against the bright window, while shadow edges on the left dissolve into the surrounding dark. There's visible impasto (thick paint) building texture on the flower cluster.
a working sequence
Establish the composition and value foundation
Lightly block in the major shapes with charcoal or thin wash: the vase position (slightly left of center), the window frame divisions, the book leaning against the vase, and the mass of foliage. Use this step to establish where light and shadow fall. The vase needs a clear vertical axis; the flowers sit in a mounded form above it.
Paint the background wall and window
Block in the wall with muted blue-green (#597579 and #91a096 mixed), leaving the window area lighter (#a7bfb8). The wall isn't uniform—subtle value shifts suggest form and light direction. Paint the outdoor landscape visible through the window: greens and blues for distant trees and sky. Keep edges soft where interior meets window light.
Establish the vase and deep shadows
Paint the vase body in warm mid-tone (#7b7d77), then immediately establish the dark interior and cast shadows with #4b5254. These dark anchors ground the composition. The shadow beneath and to the left of the flowers should be decisive and dark—this creates contrast with the bright flowers above.
Build the foliage base
Lay in the green foliage mass with loose, directional strokes using #91a096 and touches of #597579. Don't blend smoothly—let brushstrokes show. The foliage should feel organic and airy, not solid. This is the foundation that flowers will sit atop; suggest leaves and stems without overworking.
Place the flower masses by color and value
Block in the white daisy flowers first (#c8d2c1 with yellow ochre centers), as they're your brightest accent and eye-draw. Then add the pink and mauve flowers around them—these require white + alizarin or rose mixed into mid-tone (#a7bfb8 base). Place purple flowers lower in the arrangement. Don't detail individual petals yet; establish color relationships and where each flower mass lives.
Develop flower petals and foliage interaction
Now suggest individual petals with directional strokes. Daisies need darker centers (ochre brown). Add depth by placing darker foliage (greens mixed with ultramarine) between and behind flowers. The pink and purple flowers should have some definition at their edges where they catch light. Vary petal strokes—some sharp, some soft—to feel gestural rather than botanical.
Paint the book, apples, and foreground details
The open book with portrait goes on the left in shadow; paint the figure with ochre and ultramarine for form, keeping it sketchy. The apples are warm browns and russets (#7b7d77 + alizarin) sitting in deep shadow. Add a few white cloth folds beneath to provide contrast and anchor the foreground.
Refine values and add final accents
Step back and assess: are the flowers sufficiently bright against the shadow? Are the window panes luminous? Add brightest highlights where light hits petal edges and window glass with nearly pure #c8d2c1. Soften any edges that feel too hard, sharpen any that have gone muddy. The foliage should peek through the flowers in places—final scumbles of dark green add depth.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
related guides