
plate no. 3100
Alfred Freddy Krupa, 2007
what to study here
It shows how a resolved face set against bare outline, with one dark accent and exposed paper, can organize a whole drawing.
This is a strict right-profile pencil portrait that stops on purpose: the face is modeled and the neck, shoulders and back of the head stay as bare outline. Study how the drawing separates those two states. Light comes from the front-left and the form is built in soft gradations around the eye socket, cheekbone and nostril, with the stumped graphite blended smooth. The eye is the only truly dark accent, so it works as the focal point and sets the value scale for everything else. The paper is the lightest value and is left showing on the forehead, nose bridge and cheekbone. Most of the face sits in warm mid-tones, so form comes from gentle shifts and not from heavy contrast. Crisp line marks the profile contour, chin, mouth and ear, while hatching in the hair follows the curve of the skull. Look at how decisive the change from modeled face to outline is, with no tonal bridge between them. In a profile, small errors in the angle of the forehead, nose and chin damage the likeness, so check proportion before you commit to any tone.
key decision
The artist kept the eye as the only truly dark value and held the rest of the face to soft mid-tone gradation. The neck and shoulders were left as outline with no tonal modeling.
recreation guide
Alfred Freddy Krupa’s 'Unfinished portrait. Dad' (2007) is a work executed in pencil, aligning with the genre of portrait painting which aims to represent a specific human subject and achieve a recognizable likeness (Source 2). As a piece associated with New Realism, it likely emphasizes the 'minute visual expression' and 'artistic accuracy' described in drawing theory, where the goal is not merely scientific replication but the conveyance of emotional significance and form (Source 4). The title 'Unfinished' suggests an adherence to the practice of leaving works in a state that highlights the process or the raw observation, potentially avoiding the 'fatal' over-correction that can obscure lucidity in more finished mediums (Source 1).
estimated time
10-15 hours over 3-5 sessions
materials
4 items
steps
5 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Graphite pencils (various grades, e.g., 2B-6B) | Primary medium for drawing and shading, allowing for the 'minute visual expression' required for portrait likeness. | — |
| Kneaded eraser or bread | To lift graphite for corrections and highlights. Source 1 notes that charcoal (and by extension dry media like pencil) offers 'none whatever to bread' for correction, emphasizing the need for non-destructive editing tools. | — |
| High-quality drawing paper or toned paper | Surface for the pencil work. While the source specifies 'canvas' for oil, pencil portraits typically require a textured surface to hold graphite. | — |
| Hand-mirror | To compare the drawing with the sitter's face, as advised in Source 1 to 'obviate the doubt' regarding scale and proportion. | — |
preparation
surface prep
Since the medium is pencil, traditional oil ground preparation is not applicable. However, consistent with the artist's general practice of New Realism, the surface should be clean and free of dust to allow for precise graphite application. If using toned paper, ensure it is properly sized to prevent excessive graphite absorption.
underdrawing
The entire work is the underdrawing. Source 3 notes that for portraits, artists may first do a 'complete pencil... sketch' which is particularly useful if the sitter's time is limited. In this case, the pencil sketch *is* the final work. The artist should focus on establishing the 'general form, then a rough likeness' (Source 3) before refining details.
underpainting
Not applicable. The medium is dry pencil. Source 1 advises against putting down paint with 'obvious errors in construction or drawing,' implying that the drawing stage is critical and must be resolved before any wet media is applied. Here, the drawing is the final layer.
color palette
Graphite Gray/Black
Pure graphite pigment
Creating tonal values, shadows, and highlights. Source 4 emphasizes that drawing must present form in a 'more vivid manner than we ordinarily see them in nature,' requiring a full range of tonal values.
Paper White (Negative Space)
Unmarked paper surface
Highlights and light areas. Source 1 suggests using a 'dry brush to model with,' which in pencil terms translates to leaving white space or lifting graphite to create light.
composition
While specific compositional details of 'Dad' are not described in the sources, general portrait composition principles apply. Source 7 suggests that the 'prominent subject should be off-centre' unless a formal composition is desired, and that 'exact bisections of the picture space should be avoided.' The artist should ensure there is a 'center of interest' (likely the eyes or face) to prevent the work from becoming a mere pattern. The direction of the viewer's eye should lead around the elements before leading out (Source 7).
step by step
underdrawing
step 01
Position the sitter and the drawing surface on the same level. Use a hand-mirror to compare the drawing with the sitter's face, holding the mirror at arm's length to check proportions.
Tip — Source 1 advises to 'go back as far as you can to compare the drawing — with nature, through the hand-glass' to avoid scale errors.
Mirror comparison for proportion
step 02
Sketch the general form and rough likeness using light graphite strokes. Focus on the head and hands first, as these are the most critical areas for likeness (Source 3).
Tip — Source 3 notes that in many studios, the master does only the head and hands. Prioritize these areas for accuracy.
Blocking in forms
refining
step 03
Make all corrections while in the graphite stage. Use a kneaded eraser or bread to lift graphite where needed. Do not proceed to heavy shading until the construction is correct.
Tip — Source 1 warns that 'much correcting in paint is fatal to lucidity,' and while this is pencil, the principle of fixing errors early applies to maintain clarity.
Corrective erasing
step 04
Develop tonal values to create depth and form. Use 'minute visual expression' to capture the emotional significance of the subject, rather than just scientific accuracy (Source 4).
Tip — Source 4 states that artistic accuracy depends on conveying 'particular emotional significance,' so focus on the character of the 'Dad' rather than just photorealism.
Tonal modeling
finishing
step 05
Leave the work 'unfinished' as per the title. Avoid over-working the details. Source 1 suggests that 'one painting will not suffice to complete the study,' implying a layered approach, but for a pencil work, stopping before it becomes 'over-finished' preserves the immediacy.
Tip — Ensure the 'center of interest' remains clear (Source 7). Do not add unnecessary detail to background or clothing if it distracts from the face.
Controlled incompleteness
critical techniques
Mirror Comparison
Used to verify proportions and likeness by comparing the drawing to the sitter via reflection. This helps avoid the 'doubt that often arises when the picture is nearer to one than the sitter' (Source 1).
Artistic Accuracy over Scientific Accuracy
Focusing on the 'emotional significance' and 'vivid manner' of the form rather than just factual replication. This aligns with the New Realism style's attention to detail but with expressive intent (Source 4).
Early Correction
Fixing errors in the initial drawing stage using erasers/bread before committing to heavy shading. This prevents 'fatal' loss of lucidity (Source 1).
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
The Practice of Oil Painting↗
The Practice and Science of Drawing↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia: Portrait painting↗
Wikipedia: Composition (visual arts)↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
Light streams from the front-left, illuminating the face and modeling its three-dimensional form through soft shadows that gather around the eye socket, cheekbone, and nostril. The eye is the darkest accent and the natural focal point. The portrait is a strict right-profile view centered in the frame, but it halts abruptly—the neck, shoulders, and back of the head are left as bare outline, creating a stark contrast between the finished face and the skeletal framework below.
value structure
The entire drawing lives in warm mid-tones, with the paper itself as the brightest value and the eye as the only truly dark accent. Shadows are subtle and concentrated around the eye socket, nostril, and the right side of the face, creating form through gentle gradation rather than bold contrast. The transition from modeled face to outlined neck is decisive and crisp, with no tonal modeling in the underdeveloped regions.
observed palette and mixes
#ecdfb4
HB graphite on warm paper; lightest reflected light
Forehead, bridge of nose, cheekbone highlights—the paper tone itself
#e0c58a
HB to 2B graphite; warm mid-tone
General face plane, most of the illuminated forehead and cheek
#dbc485
2B graphite; mid-tone shadow
Cheek shadow, side of face, modeling the jaw and temple
#d9bd7c
2B to 4B graphite; darker mid-shadow
Lower cheek shadow, nostril edge, lines defining the profile
#c8a868
4B graphite; deep shadow
Eye socket, pupil and iris, nostril interior—darkest tones in the piece
edges and brushwork
The face is rendered with soft, blended edges—graphite is worked and stumped to create smooth tonal transitions that model the forehead, cheekbone, and nostril without harsh lines. Visible hatching appears in the hair, with strokes following the curve of the skull. The profile outline and facial contours (chin, mouth, ear) are drawn with crisp, deliberate line work that anchors the form. Directional marks are subtle but present, particularly along the cheek's convexity and within the hair.
a working sequence
Establish proportion and outline
Lightly sketch the skull's overall shape and the profile contour. Pay obsessive attention to the angle of the forehead, the jut of the nose, the set of the chin, and the position of the ear relative to the jaw. This profile view is unforgiving—any error in proportion destroys the likeness. Indicate the eye oval, nostril placement, and mouth line. Keep your lines featherlight; you're building a scaffold, not committing to tone.
Map the light and shadow zones
Using very light pressure, identify where light falls (front of forehead, nose ridge, cheekbone plane) and where shadow gathers (eye socket, under the cheekbone, the side of the face). Think of the head as a simple form receiving frontal-left light. Mark these zones with gentle tone—no blending yet, just establishing the value territories.
Build the eye—your value anchor
The eye is the darkest element and sets the scale for the entire piece. Shadow the upper lid and socket carefully, then render the iris and pupil with your firmest pressure. Notice how the brow casts a shadow across the lid, and how the eye sits back in its socket. If this reads convincingly, everything else will follow.
Model the nose and cheekbone
Layer tone across the bridge of the nose and the cheek plane, following the underlying bone structure. The nose is defined primarily by the nostril shadow and a subtle highlight along its ridge. The cheek should show a gentle transition from illuminated plane to shadow, creating roundness. The shadow strengthens as it wraps around toward the ear.
Define the mouth and jaw
The lips are understated—defined more by subtle value shifts than by hard lines. The lower lip has a crisp contour that anchors the mouth. The jaw recedes into shadow; use value to push it back spatially and establish the chin's angle. The corner of the mouth is just a suggestion, not overworked.
Blend and unify the face
Using a blending stump or tortillon, soften transitions between light and shadow across the face. Work with intention—preserve the bony landmarks (eye socket, cheekbone, nose ridge) while smoothing the gradations. The paper tone should read as mid-tone luminosity, not white. Most of the face should feel cohesive and warm.
Develop the ear and sketch the lower plane
Render the ear with careful attention to its spiral structure and the shadow within its form. Shade the area behind and below the ear to push it back in space. Suggest the back of the head and neck with minimal, crisp line work only—just enough to anchor the profile outline. Leave the shoulders and lower neck as bare outline to maintain the unfinished aesthetic.
Add texture, crisp contours, and final accents
Use directional hatching to suggest hair texture along the top and sides of the head, following the skull's form underneath. Sharpen the profile outline with a decisive line. Add any final dark accents to reinforce the eye and nostril. Step back—the piece should feel deliberately incomplete, with the face developed to a particular point and everything else suggested.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
related guides
in this vein

Old wooden cottage in the snow
Alfred Freddy Krupa

Delta Farms
Wayne Thiebaud

Morning fresh snow: chestnuts (en plein air)
Alfred Freddy Krupa

House by the Railroad
Edward Hopper

The Mansard Roof
Edward Hopper

Spring Planting, Greenwich Village
John French Sloan

Renganeschi's Saturday Night
John French Sloan

Fishing Port, Gloucester
John French Sloan