
plate no. 7010
William Merritt Chase, 1887
what to study here
It shows how a saturated yellow-green middle value and clean mauve shadows can carry a light effect without relying on the lightest lights.
Start with the value structure. Squint and the picture breaks into three zones: pale sky, a luminous yellow-green grass middle ground, and a dark tree line. The grass sits in a distinct middle value and reads bright because of its saturation, not because it is light. Then look at the shadows on that grass. They are cool mauve rather than gray-blue, which sets up a warm-cool contrast against the yellow-green and carries the light effect. The sky moves from periwinkle-blue to peachy-rose at the horizon, and its edges dissolve softly into the trees. The brushwork is loose and directional: trees are built from strokes of varied greens, figures are reduced to ochre and white accents, and the parasol is a few pink strokes. The flower bed in the lower right is the most defined passage, a secondary focal point against the cool grass. Notice how the sandy path leads the eye from the woman with the parasol into the distance, and how the buildings and steeple stay subordinate.
key decision
Chase kept the grass as a saturated yellow-green middle value and shadowed it with cool mauve instead of gray-blue. That warm-cool contrast carries the light.
recreation guide
William Merritt Chase’s *Tompkins Park, Brooklyn* (1887) represents a pivotal moment in his career, marking his transition toward landscape painting in an Impressionist style. According to art-historical records, Chase began painting landscapes in earnest in the late 1880s, a shift likely influenced by the landmark 1886 New York exhibition of French Impressionist works (Source 7). While Chase is often celebrated for his portraits and domestic scenes, this work belongs to his series of urban park landscapes, which he painted with a 'noble sense of color' and a loosely brushed technique reminiscent of his Munich training (Source 7). The painting reflects the broader American landscape tradition, which, while rooted in the detailed realism of the Hudson River School, was evolving to embrace the looser, light-focused aesthetics of European Impressionism (Source 2, Source 4).
estimated time
20-30 hours over 5-7 sessions
materials
4 items
steps
5 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Oil paints (primary colors: Ultramarine, Vermilion, Yellow Ochre, White) | Chase was known for his fluency in oil painting and his 'noble sense of color' (Source 7). Impressionist practice relies on broken color and optical mixing. | High-quality tube oils; avoid earth tones if aiming for the bright, airy quality of his park scenes. |
| Canvas or linen panel | Standard support for oil landscapes of this period. | Pre-primed linen canvas. |
| Bristle brushes (flat and filbert) | To achieve the 'loosely brushed style' Chase employed in his figurative and landscape works (Source 6, Source 7). | Hog bristle brushes. |
| Linseed oil or turpentine | Medium for glazing and scumbling, techniques discussed in general oil painting practice relevant to the era (Source 5). | Stand oil or odorless mineral spirits. |
preparation
surface prep
Chase worked in a studio environment (Tenth Street Studio Building) and likely used standard primed canvases of the late 19th century. While specific ground preparation for this exact canvas is not detailed in the sources, the general practice of the period involved oil grounds to facilitate the 'loosely brushed' application (Source 6, Source 8).
underdrawing
The sources do not explicitly describe Chase’s underdrawing methods for landscapes. However, given his Impressionist approach and 'loosely brushed style,' it is likely that he employed minimal preliminary sketching, perhaps using thin paint or charcoal directly on the canvas to block in major masses of light and shadow, consistent with the direct painting methods of the Barbizon and Impressionist schools (Source 2, Source 7).
underpainting
General oil painting texts from the period discuss the use of grisaille (monochrome underpainting) followed by glazing and scumbling (Source 5). While Chase’s specific use of underpainting in *Tompkins Park* is not explicitly cited, his Munich training under Karl von Piloty involved rigorous academic techniques that may have included tonal underpainting before applying color. However, his later Impressionist works suggest a more direct application of color. It is recommended to use a neutral tonal underpainting to establish values before applying the vibrant colors characteristic of his 'noble sense of color' (Source 5, Source 7).
color palette
Vibrant Greens and Blues
Ultramarine, Viridian, Yellow Ochre, White
Depicting the park foliage and sky. Chase’s landscapes are noted for their powerful rendering of color masses (Source 7).
Warm Earth Tones
Burnt Sienna, Raw Umber
Shadows and tree trunks, providing contrast to the bright highlights.
Bright Whites and Yellows
Titanium White, Cadmium Yellow
Capturing the sunlight and atmospheric effects, consistent with Impressionist light studies.
composition
Landscape painting traditionally arranges natural scenery into a coherent composition, often including the sky as a major element (Source 1). Chase’s park scenes likely feature a wide view with elements arranged to create depth. While specific compositional details of *Tompkins Park* are not described in the sources, Chase’s general practice involved featuring people prominently in his landscapes, though this specific work may focus more on the scenery itself as part of his 'series of landscape subjects' (Source 7). The composition should balance the 'peaceful agriculture and remaining wilderness' aesthetic common in American landscape art, albeit with an Impressionist looseness (Source 2).
step by step
underdrawing
step 01
Lightly sketch the major compositional elements: the horizon line, tree masses, and any figures or paths. Keep lines loose and minimal.
Tip — Avoid hard lines; think in terms of light and shadow masses.
Direct sketching
underpainting
step 02
Apply a thin wash of neutral tones (grisaille) to establish the value structure of the painting. This helps in managing the 'chiaro-scuro' and gradation of light (Source 3).
Tip — Ensure the underpainting is dry before proceeding to avoid muddying the colors.
Grisaille
first pass
step 03
Block in the major color masses using broad, loose brushstrokes. Focus on the sky and large tree forms. Use the 'loosely brushed style' characteristic of Chase’s Munich training and later Impressionist work (Source 6, Source 7).
Tip — Pay attention to the 'law of simultaneous contrast' to enhance the vibrancy of adjacent colors (Source 3).
Alla prima (wet-on-wet)
refining
step 04
Add details and refine the edges. Use glazing and scumbling techniques to adjust tones and create atmospheric depth. Glazing involves applying transparent coats of color, while scumbling uses semi-opaque paint to modify underlying tones (Source 5).
Tip — Use scumbling over darker grounds to create a 'grey bloom' or atmospheric haze, typical of landscape effects (Source 5).
Glazing and Scumbling
finishing
step 05
Review the overall composition for coherence and balance. Ensure the 'noble sense of color' is maintained, with powerful rendering of light and shadow (Source 7).
Tip — Step back frequently to assess the overall effect rather than getting lost in details.
Final adjustments
critical techniques
Loose Brushwork
Chase employed a 'loosely brushed style' in his figurative and landscape works, influenced by his Munich instructors and later Impressionist trends (Source 6, Source 7).
Color Contrast
Utilizing the principles of color contrast to enhance the visual impact of the landscape. Juxtaposing colors can produce a 'true gradation of light' and harmonize the composition (Source 3).
Glazing and Scumbling
These techniques allow for the modification of tones and the creation of atmospheric effects. Scumbling over darker grounds can produce a 'grey bloom,' useful for depicting distant elements or haze (Source 5).
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
Laws of Contrast of Colour↗
The Practice of Oil Painting↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia bio — William Merritt Chase↗
Wikipedia: Landscape painting↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
Late afternoon light bathes the park in diffuse, soft illumination from above, creating cool lavender-blue shadows across the bright yellow-green grass while the sky shifts from periwinkle-blue to warm peachy-rose near the horizon. Your eye lands first on the woman with the red-hatted pink parasol in the lower left foreground, then travels along the sandy path as it curves away, populated with leisurely figures in pale summer dress. The dark tree masses frame both edges and recede into atmospheric distance, with buildings and a steeple anchoring the middle ground on the right. A vibrant flower bed of reds, oranges, whites, and pinks occupies the lower right, its concentrated color making it a secondary focal point against the cool grass.
value structure
The lightest lights are the sky and the sandy path; the darkest darks live in tree shadows and deep foliage. The grass establishes a distinct middle value that reads as bright yet solid, distinguished from the lighter sky and lighter path by its yellow-green saturation. When you squint, three clear zones emerge: the pale sky, the luminous grass middle-ground, and the dark tree line silhouette. Shadow areas on the grass carry distinctly cool mauve tones rather than pure gray-blue, grounding the color story.
observed palette and mixes
#2d3528
ultramarine blue + burnt sienna + viridian
Deepest tree shadows and dark foliage masses, particularly in tree canopies on left and center
#72754d
yellow ochre + ultramarine + cadmium green
Mid-tone tree foliage and weathered branch structure visible between light passages
#645a3f
raw sienna + yellow ochre + touch of ultramarine
Sandy path winding through the park, warm and slightly muted
#978fa4
ultramarine + alizarin crimson + white
Mauve-tinted shadows across the grass, cool shadow areas on buildings, and underpainting for mauve foliage
#887a51
yellow ochre + ultramarine + cadmium red
Warm transitional green-browns in middle-distance foliage and dried grass passages
#c2a5aa
alizarin crimson + ultramarine + white + touch of yellow ochre
Pale mauve tones in distant building shadows and atmospheric perspective in foliage
edges and brushwork
Chase employs loose, broken brushwork throughout—trees are suggested with directional strokes of varied greens rather than rendered leaves, and the sky is smoothly blended with soft edges that dissolve into the tree line. Figures are simplified to minimal ochre and white accents with barely-indicated limbs; the woman's parasol is just a few decisive pink strokes. The flower bed shows the most definition with individual blooms suggested through warm reds and whites, though never laboriously detailed. Grass shadows feature visible directional brushwork that follows the contours of the ground.
a working sequence
Establish the sky and distant atmosphere
Block in the entire sky with a soft periwinkle-blue (ultramarine + alizarin + white), warmer and more peachy-rose toward the horizon. Keep edges soft and atmospheric; the sky should feel luminous and overcast, not dramatic. Establish the warm cloud passages with pale rose-mauve tones blending into the blue.
Silhouette the tree line
While the sky is still wet or damp, lay in the dark tree masses as a unified dark shape across the middle distance and horizon. Use your darkest mix (ultramarine + burnt sienna + viridian) to establish the value difference decisively. Don't worry about detail—this is the shadow mass that anchors everything behind it. Leave the steeple pale against this dark.
Block the grass and path
Establish the foreground grass in its bright yellow-green (cadmium yellow + viridian, lightened with white). Paint the sandy path using your warm tan (raw sienna + yellow ochre). Notice the grass is notably yellow-toned, not just green. Allow the path to curve naturally into the distance, narrowing slightly.
Place the cool shadow structure on grass
Add the violet-mauve shadows across the grass (ultramarine + alizarin + white), following the diagonal direction of light. These shadows are not arbitrary—they follow where the tree canopy casts shade and where figures create small shadows. This cool-warm contrast between the sunny yellow-grass and cool mauve shadows is essential to the painting's light effect.
Plant the flower bed and focal figures
In the lower right, establish the flower bed with bright reds (alizarin or cadmium red), oranges (cadmium orange), whites, and mauve accents, keeping brushstrokes loose and impressionistic—suggest blooms, don't render every petal. In the lower left foreground, place the woman with the pink parasol using warm ochre for her dress and a few definitive pink strokes for the parasol. Add the brown chairs as simple rectangular shapes.
Develop tree foliage with varied greens
Return to the tree masses and add variation using your yellow-ochre-based greens (#72754d mix) in the lit passages and mid-tones. Layer warm brown-greens (#887a51) in sunlit foliage edges. Avoid uniform green; let trees show structure through value shifts and warm-cool transitions. Add the distinctive cypress-like steeple shape with pale tan and mauve.
Populate with figures and architectural detail
Scatter figures throughout the middle and background park using pale ochre, cream, and white strokes with minimal red accents (hats, dresses). Figures should be tiny suggestions rather than rendered faces—a few strokes suffice. Add the tan-orange buildings on the right middle-distance, keeping them simple and not overdetailed. The figures and buildings should feel atmospheric and distant.
Refine edges and atmospheric depth
Soften edges where the distant trees meet sky, making them slightly hazier than foreground elements. Increase the saturation and value clarity of foreground grass and the flower bed. Add final touches to the parasol and any key figure accents. Check that your mauve shadow tones read distinctly cool against the yellow-green grass—this contrast is what makes the light feel real.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
related guides
in this vein