
plate no. 9217
William Merritt Chase, 1903
what to study here
It shows how warm, close-valued color and soft edges can describe a street and recession without detail or strong contrast.
Study how a painting can hold together on a compressed value range. The vision read gives three bands: a pale cream-yellow sky as the lightest note, a mid-light tan street, warm mid-tone facades, and darks held back to deep reddish-browns in windows and doorways rather than black. Squint and check that those layers separate without hard contrast. Look at the edges: rooflines blur into the sky, building planes shift softly, and shadows blend into walls, while the strokes in the street and sky stay visible and decisive. Detail is left out and form comes from value and color placement. The red roofs and the bright red flowers on the left building are the saturated notes, and the small figures lead the eye down the street. Note how buildings step back in atmospheric perspective. Copy the value structure first, then the edge handling, and resist adding architectural detail.
key decision
Chase kept the values compressed, with a pale sky, mid-light street and facades, and only warm reddish-brown darks. He let color placement and soft, broken edges carry the form instead of drawn detail.
recreation guide
William Merritt Chase’s *The Red Roofs of Haarlem* (1903) is a quintessential example of his mature Impressionist landscape style, characterized by a 'noble sense of color' and loose, fluent brushwork (Source 2). Painted during a European summer tour with his students, the work reflects Chase’s exposure to Frans Hals in Haarlem, though the painting itself is a cityscape rather than a figure study (Source 2). The artwork exemplifies Chase’s ability to capture atmospheric effects and light through a palette that likely utilizes earth tones and substantial pigments, consistent with the advice to use colors that are 'substantial' and dry easily (Source 1). The composition relies on the principles of simultaneous contrast to create depth and luminosity without relying on rigid outlines, adhering to the Impressionist goal of rendering the 'soul' of the scene through color interaction rather than detailed topographical accuracy (Source 1, Source 3).
estimated time
20-30 hours over 5-7 sessions
materials
5 items
steps
5 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Oil paints (White Lead or Titanium White, Yellow Ochre, Red Ochre, Vermilion/Cinnabar, Ultramarine/Indigo, Ivory Black) | Primary palette for mixing substantial, fixed tones as recommended for oil painting solidity. | Titanium White (safer alternative to White Lead), Cadmium Red/Yellow (if seeking high chroma, though earths are preferred for stability per Source 1) |
| Linseed oil or painting varnish | Medium to adjust transparency and drying time; Source 5 notes the importance of controlling oil quantity. | Stand Oil or Galkyd for modern alkyd mediums |
| Canvas sized with casein paste or traditional rabbit-skin glue | Provides a white, impervious ground that allows for correct judgment of color transparency and tone. | Pre-primed linen or cotton canvas with acrylic gesso |
| White palette (wood or glass) | Essential for accurate color mixing; Source 5 advises a white, oil-impermeable palette to keep tones light and prevent chemical absorption. | White ceramic or tempered glass palette |
| Brushes (flat and filbert) | For applying loose, fluent brushstrokes characteristic of Chase’s style. | Synthetic or natural bristle brushes |
preparation
surface prep
The canvas should be sized with a white ground, such as casein paste or a traditional size, to ensure it is 'quite impervious to oil' and provides a neutral, light base for judging tones (Source 5). This preparation helps maintain the 'perfect fixedness' and covering qualities of the pigments (Source 1).
underdrawing
Chase’s Impressionist style suggests a minimal or non-existent visible underdrawing. Source 5 notes that outlines can be done in oil or watercolor, but given Chase’s 'loosely brushed style' (Source 4) and the Impressionist emphasis on color over line, the artist likely sketched lightly in oil or directly with paint, avoiding hard lines that would contradict the 'simultaneous contrast' effects (Source 3).
underpainting
A thin wash of neutral tone or a direct alla prima approach is likely. Source 5 mentions that if a watercolor sketch is used, it should be sealed with varnish before oil application, but Chase’s fluency in oil suggests he may have worked directly in oil to capture the 'subtle elusive tints' (Source 2).
color palette
White
White Lead (historical) or Titanium White
Highlights and lightening tones; Source 1 lists 'Chalk white' and 'White lead' as foundational.
Yellow Ochre
Natural Yellow Ochre
Earth tones, shadows, and neutralizing mixes; Source 1 highlights its 'perfect fixedness' and utility for 'broken tones'.
Red Ochre/Vermilion
Red Ochre or Cinnabar (Vermilion)
The 'Red Roofs' and warm accents; Source 1 lists 'Red ochre' and 'Cinnabar' as substantial colors.
Blue
Indigo or Ultramarine
Sky and cool shadows; Source 1 lists 'Indigo' and 'Blue pulverised enamels'.
Black
Ivory Black or Vine Black
Deep shadows and contrast; Source 1 lists 'Various blacks prepared from the combustion of different bodies, e.g., ivory'.
composition
The composition likely utilizes the principle of 'simultaneous contrast' to create depth and luminosity, where juxtaposed colors enhance each other’s intensity (Source 3). Chase’s landscapes often feature a 'noble sense of color' with powerful rendering of masses (Source 2). The arrangement of roofs and sky would follow the 'law of contrast of colour' to produce chiaroscuro effects without relying on hard outlines (Source 3).
step by step
underdrawing
step 02
Lightly sketch the major forms of the roofs and sky using a thin mixture of oil paint or a watercolor wash sealed with varnish.
Tip — Avoid heavy lines; focus on the placement of masses to facilitate color contrast (Source 5, Source 3).
Outline in Oil or Watercolor
first pass
step 03
Apply broad, loose brushstrokes of substantial colors (ochres, reds, blues) to establish the main masses of the roofs and sky.
Tip — Use colors that are 'substantial' and dry easily to maintain the integrity of the painting (Source 1).
Alla Prima / Loose Brushwork
refining
step 04
Refine the edges and adjust tones by juxtaposing contrasting colors to enhance luminosity and depth, rather than blending smoothly.
Tip — Observe how placing a light tint next to a dark one enhances the gradation of light (Source 3).
Simultaneous Contrast
finishing
step 05
Add final highlights and deep shadows, ensuring the 'noble sense of color' is maintained without muddying the hues.
Tip — Avoid adding black to darken colors if it causes hue shifts; use complements instead (Source 6).
Color Harmony
surfaceprep
step 01
Prepare a white, oil-impermeable palette and ensure the canvas is properly sized with a white ground to allow for accurate color judgment.
Tip — Ensure the palette is clean and white to prevent color contamination and maintain lightness (Source 5).
Palette and Ground Preparation
critical techniques
Simultaneous Contrast
Juxtaposing colors to enhance their perceived intensity and create depth without blending, a key principle in Impressionism.
Use of Substantial Pigments
Selecting colors that are chemically stable and cover well, such as ochres and earths, to ensure the painting's longevity and visual clarity.
Loose Brushwork
Applying paint in fluent, visible strokes to capture the impression of light and atmosphere, characteristic of Chase’s style.
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
The Science of Painting↗
Laws of Contrast of Colour↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia bio — William Merritt Chase↗
Wikipedia: Color theory↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
Light streams from above, washing the canvas in warm, diffused noon light that creates a pale cream-yellow sky dominating the upper half. The street recedes into this bright distance, flanked by red-roofed buildings that step back in atmospheric perspective. Bright red flowers on the left building and scattered figures in the street draw the eye down the composition, while shadows pool dark in doorways and windows, grounding the warmth above.
value structure
The painting hinges on a compressed value range of lights and mid-lights: the pale cream sky is nearly the lightest note, the warm tan street is mid-light, and the building facades are warm mid-tones. Darkest darks appear only in shadows and window openings—deep reddish-browns that read as shadow rather than true black. When you squint, you see three clear value layers: sky (lightest), buildings and street (middle band), and shadows (darkest accents).
observed palette and mixes
#f1d7a2
Titanium white + raw sienna, warmed with touch of cadmium red
The pale sky, particularly the bright central opening above the street
#c99c6b
Titanium white + burnt sienna + raw umber
Street surface and lighter building facades catching direct light
#bf8c5d
Burnt sienna + raw sienna + white
Mid-tone building walls and roofs, primary warm mass
#ac6740
Cadmium red + burnt sienna + touch of raw umber
The red tile roofs, particularly the pitched roofs against sky
#895639
Burnt sienna + raw umber + alizarin
Shaded sides of buildings and warm shadow areas
#612d21
Raw umber + alizarin + touch of ultramarine blue
Deepest shadows in windows, doorways, and shadow recesses
edges and brushwork
Edges are consistently soft and broken throughout—the rooflines blur into sky, building planes read as soft transitions rather than hard lines, and shadows blend into walls. Brushstrokes remain visible and decisive, particularly across the street and sky where the paint is dragged or dabbed in loose gestures. The handling resists detail work entirely, instead relying on value and color placement to suggest form.
a working sequence
Tone the canvas and block sky
Establish a warm neutral underwash across the entire canvas using burnt sienna and raw umber. Then lay in the sky with a pale mixture of titanium white + raw sienna + touch of cadmium red, keeping it luminous and high-keyed. Leave the horizon soft—don't render a hard line where sky meets buildings.
Block primary building masses
Using a warm burnt sienna + raw umber mix, roughly indicate both building complexes as large geometric shapes stepping back into space. Keep edges soft and focus on the proportions of how the buildings frame the street. Don't worry about individual windows yet—just establish the warm value that dominates the composition.
Establish street and perspective
Paint the street surface with a light warm tan (white + raw sienna + touch of burnt sienna). Make it recede convincingly by keeping it narrower in the distance and slightly warmer in tone as it retreats. This step locks in the perspective cage that everything else sits within.
Define roofs and major planes
Introduce the warm red roofs using cadmium red + burnt sienna, laying them in with confident strokes. The pitched roofs on the left and the more distant roof angles on the right should feel warm and luminous but not jarring—they should sit comfortably within the overall warm harmony. Define the main shadow side of buildings with a darker burnt sienna + raw umber mix.
Place flowers, figures, and dark accents
Add the bright red potted flowers on the left building with pure cadmium red—they provide the most saturated color note and draw the eye immediately. Sketch in small figures on the street (they're quite small and impressionistic). Drop in the deepest darks in window openings and doorways using raw umber + alizarin, which reads as shadow rather than pure black.
Add vegetation and soften transitions
Block in the muted dark green foliage on the right building's corner—it should feel darker and cooler than the warm buildings but still harmonize. Soften transitions between values by blending where buildings meet sky and where shadows meet lit surfaces. The goal is visual unity through warmth, not clarity of edge.
Refine values and atmosphere
Adjust building values so they recede convincingly—objects further back should lose saturation and definition slightly. Add accent strokes in the street and sky to suggest light and movement. The painting should read as suffused in warm, diffuse afternoon light rather than sharply rendered.
Final check and integration
Step back and assess whether the values read clearly when you squint. The sky should feel like the brightest area, the street like mid-light, buildings like warm mid-tones, and shadows like distinct but warm darks. Make any final adjustments to edges and ensure no element breaks the overall warm color harmony. Resist the urge to add detail—let loose brushwork and color placement carry the entire effect.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
related guides
in this vein