
plate no. 3372
William Merritt Chase, 1885
what to study here
It shows how to simplify reflections in pastel using broken color, selective hard edges, and visible paper tooth while keeping clear value zones.
Study how the water is handled as a middle value, not a pale flat zone. The vision analysis describes it as scattered light accents and broken green color, with small hard dark green or blue marks that read as reflections without rendering every detail. The edges carry the lesson. The bridge arches hold the crispest edges, while water and foliage blur into each other with feathered, directional strokes. Pastel has been blended with stumps in places, but the paper tooth still shows, and that texture does much of the shimmer. Squint and you get two zones: a warm, sunlit stone foreground at upper left, and everything beyond it (water, three-arch bridge, trees) pushed into cooler, softer tones. Near-black sits only under the arches and in the deepest foliage, so those small darks anchor the depth. Notice also the viewpoint: close to the embankment edge, looking along the canal rather than across it. Copy the restraint: simplify reflections, keep sharp edges for the architecture, and avoid smoothing the surface.
key decision
Chase kept the water as a complex middle value with fractured color and a few sharp dark accents, instead of a pale mirror. Hard edges are reserved for the bridge arches.
recreation guide
William Merritt Chase’s 'Reflections' (1885) is a landscape executed in pastel, a medium that allows for the rapid capture of light and atmosphere characteristic of Impressionism. Chase, trained in Munich under Karl von Piloty and Alexander von Wagner, developed a loosely brushed style that emphasized broad masses of color and light over detailed finish (Source 4). While the provided sources focus heavily on watercolor and oil painting theories, they offer critical insights into the material science of the period, particularly regarding the importance of support quality and the optical effects of color contrast. The artwork likely relies on the artist’s ability to perceive and imitate the modifications of light on the model, utilizing the law of simultaneous contrast to harmonize colors inherent to the natural scene (Source 7).
estimated time
10-15 hours over 3-4 sessions
materials
4 items
steps
5 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| High-quality pastel paper | Support for the pastel medium. While sources discuss watercolor paper extensively, noting it should be made from linen rags and properly sized to prevent staining (Source 1), pastel requires a toothed surface to hold pigment. A heavy-weight, textured paper is essential. | Sennelier Mi-Teintes or Canson Mi-Teintes pastel paper |
| Soft pastels | Primary medium. Chase’s Impressionist style requires vibrant, pure pigments to capture light effects without the muddiness that occurs when mixing too many colors (Source 3). | Sennelier or Holbein soft pastels |
| Fixative | To preserve the work. Pastels are fragile and prone to smudging. While not explicitly detailed in the sources, preservation is a key concern in the 'Science of Painting' discussions regarding material stability (Source 1). | Krylon Workable Fixative or similar archival spray |
| Blending stumps or fingers | To soften edges and create atmospheric effects, consistent with the 'loosely brushed style' Chase employed in his figurative works (Source 4). | Paper blending stumps |
preparation
surface prep
The support must be dry and free from dampness, as moisture can cause sizing to ferment and decompose, leading to stains and loss of properties (Source 1). Although the sources discuss watercolor paper, the principle of using a stable, well-sized support applies to pastel as well to ensure the pigment adheres properly without sinking in unevenly. The paper should not have suffered from dampness since manufacture (Source 1).
underdrawing
Chase’s style is characterized by a lack of rigid outlining; he favored broad masses and loose handling (Source 4). Therefore, the underdrawing should be minimal, perhaps just light indications of major forms and horizon lines, avoiding hard contours that would contradict the Impressionist aesthetic. The artist should not be 'too much tied down to your outline' (Source 6).
underpainting
Not applicable in the traditional oil sense, but the initial layer of pastel should establish the major tonal masses. Chase’s Munich training emphasized a loosely brushed style, suggesting that the first pass should be about capturing the general impression of light and color rather than detailed rendering (Source 4).
color palette
Bright Blues and Greens
Pure ultramarine, cerulean, viridian, emerald green
Capturing the reflections in the canal and the sky. Chase’s Impressionist approach requires high chroma to depict light (Source 3).
Warm Yellows and Oranges
Cadmium yellow, ochre, raw sienna
Sunlit areas and reflections on buildings. These colors contrast with the cool blues to create vibrancy (Source 7).
Neutral Grays and Browns
Payne’s gray, burnt umber, charcoal
Shadows and structural elements. Darkening colors by adding black can shift hues, so using complements or neutral tints is preferred to maintain hue integrity (Source 3).
composition
While specific compositional details of 'Reflections' are not described in the sources, Chase’s general practice involved arranging broad masses of color to create a harmonious whole. The artist should aim to harmonize colors that are essentially inherent to the nature of the objects, using the law of simultaneous contrast to ensure that adjacent colors enhance each other rather than clash (Source 7). The composition should avoid 'smallness' and instead focus on the overall effect of light and atmosphere (Source 6).
step by step
underdrawing
step 01
Lightly sketch the major forms: the horizon line, the canal, and the buildings. Avoid hard lines; use gentle strokes to indicate placement.
Tip — Do not become 'tied down to your outline' (Source 6).
Minimal underdrawing
first pass
step 02
Apply broad strokes of pastel to establish the major color masses. Focus on the sky and water reflections, using pure colors to capture the light.
Tip — Chase’s style is 'loosely brushed' (Source 4). Work quickly to capture the impression.
Broad massing
refining
step 03
Layer additional colors to enhance contrast and depth. Use the law of simultaneous contrast: place complementary colors adjacent to each other to intensify their appearance (Source 7).
Tip — Be aware that the eye may see colors inaccurately due to mixed contrast; take breaks to reset your vision (Source 7).
Simultaneous contrast
finishing
step 04
Add final highlights and shadows. Ensure that the lights are bright and the darks are rich, but avoid muddying colors by over-mixing. Use complements to darken colors without shifting hue (Source 3).
Tip — Adding black can shift hues; use complements for darkening (Source 3).
Color mixing
varnishing
step 05
Apply a light coat of fixative to preserve the work. Ensure the paper is dry and free from dampness to prevent staining (Source 1).
Tip — Moisture can cause sizing to ferment and decompose (Source 1).
Preservation
critical techniques
Simultaneous Contrast
Used to harmonize colors and perceive modifications of light. The artist must appreciate the color peculiar to each part and the modifications received from contiguous colors (Source 7).
Loose Brushwork
Chase’s Munich training emphasized a loosely brushed style, focusing on broad masses rather than detailed finish (Source 4).
Color Mixing
Avoid adding black to darken colors, as it shifts hue. Use complements to neutralize and darken without hue shift (Source 3).
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
The Science of Painting↗
The Practice of Oil Painting↗
Laws of Contrast of Colour↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia: Color theory↗
Wikipedia bio — William Merritt Chase↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
Light falls diffusely across a sunlit stone embankment that recedes leftward into deep shadow, drawing immediate attention to the brightly illuminated foreground path. The eye moves from that warm, textured stone into the cool water below, where light and green reflections fracture the surface—the water is the emotional center, a stage for showing how reflections simplify and shimmer. A three-arch stone bridge anchors the middle distance, its arches casting warm shadows that echo into the water; trees cluster darkly beyond, framing both sides and compressing the distant view. The composition trades vertical drama for intimate recession: the viewer stands very close to the embankment edge, looking along the canal rather than across it.
value structure
Brightest lights concentrate on the stone foreground (upper left), medium-high values dominate the water and visible stone bridge, and near-black shadow lives under the bridge arches and deep in the foliated background. When squinted, two clear zones emerge: the warm, sunlit near-plane and everything beyond it (water, bridge, trees) pushed back into cooler, softer mid-and-dark tones. The water itself reads as a complex middle value with scattered light accents, not a flat pale zone—this layering is essential to the sense of depth and reflection.
observed palette and mixes
#bfc69f
Naples yellow + white, or pale ochre + cream
Brightest stones in foreground left, highlights catching on the water surface, the sun-struck bridge arch
#797f54
Raw sienna + ultramarine, or olive earth tone
Mid-tone stone surfaces of the embankment and bridge structure, warm shadows on the bridge face
#6d6543
Burnt sienna + umber, warm brown
Shadow side of bridge arches, darker stone, the warm-toned building visible to the right
#849a74
Yellow ochre + viridian + white, or sage green
Mid-tone greens in water reflection, foliage mid-tones, broken color across the water surface
#4c6040
Viridian + alizarin + ultramarine, deep forest green
Dark water in shadow, tree foliage masses in background, deepest reflections
#383d2a
Lamp black + ultramarine + brown earth, very dark neutral
Shadow cavity under bridge arches, darkest tree foliage, sharp accents in shadowed water
edges and brushwork
Edges are deliberately atmospheric and soft—the bridge arches hold the crispest edges (where architecture matters), while water and foliage blur into one another with feathered, directional strokes that suggest movement and light play rather than describe detail. Pastel dust has been worked and blended with stumps to soften transitions, especially in the water and sky glimpses; you'll see the paper tooth asserting itself, which gives the work its impressionistic shimmer. Single accent strokes—small hard marks of dark green or blue in the water—punctuate the softer handling and register as reflections without rendering every detail.
a working sequence
Establish composition lightly
Using a neutral midtone pastel on toned paper, sketch the horizontal line where stone meets water, the three bridge arches as simple curves, and the tree line as a loose silhouette in the far background. Don't worry about symmetry; the arches should feel organic and in perspective. Mark the near edge of the stone embankment on the left where it catches full light.
Block in major value zones
Use a broad pastel lay-down to establish the darkest passages: shadow under the bridge arches, the tree masses at top and sides. Then block the mid-tone bridge stones with a warm brown-gray. Leave the foreground stone pale for now. Work loosely to feel the composition's weight distribution.
Establish the water's dominant character
Layer in the water with broken strokes of pale blue-green, then overlay with warmer olive-greens where reflection mirrors the foliage and stone. The water should read as one complex shape with visible directional marks—suggest current and shimmer rather than mirror perfection. Leave flecks of the paper showing through.
Warm up the stone foreground
With pale ochre and soft cream pastels, define the sunlit stone surface on the left, leaving the shadow edge crisp where it meets the darker right side. Let the paper contribute—pastels applied loosely over toned paper suggest weathered stone better than full coverage. Add warm shadows (burnt sienna, raw umber) to show form and wear.
Refine the bridge structure
Deepen the shadow caves under each arch with dark blue-gray and warm brown shadow, working around the lighter reflection that appears in the water below. Warm the lit face of the bridge with pale ochre and burnt sienna. The bridge should feel solid and receding, with the right arch catching the most direct light.
Build atmospheric depth with foliage
Layer forest greens and cool grays into the tree masses, darkest at the very back and fading slightly toward the foreground trees on the left. Keep edges soft and broken; suggest trees with value changes and color shifts rather than leaf-by-leaf detail. A hint of warm tones (ochre) can peek through for air and light.
Intensify water reflections with accent marks
Return to the water and add darker blue-green strokes following the flow direction, then place small sharp accents of very dark color (nearly black-green) where branches or arch shadows reflect. Drag light strokes over to suggest light trails on the surface. The water should now read as alive and reflective, not flat.
Unite with atmospheric touches and final adjustments
Soften any hard edges that feel out of place with a kneaded eraser or blending stump; the eye should move gently from foreground to water to bridge to trees. Add pale sky hints where visible between foliage (light blue-gray or cream). A light spray of fixative now prevents smudging before final details. Step back—the strongest version is often the simplest.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
in this vein