
plate no. 5163
William Merritt Chase, 1909
what to study here
It shows how a high-key garden scene holds its space through three value groups, a bright leading path, and edges that soften with distance.
Start with the value structure, because the picture is built on three groups. The pale sandy path and central ground are the lightest area, the green tree masses are the darkest, and the architecture and flower clusters sit in the middle. The path is nearly as light as the sky in places, so it has to stay luminous or the recession flattens. Light comes from the upper left. The path is dragged in smooth horizontal strokes that carry the eye back to the gate, urns and balustrade. Edges get softer with distance: cypress and background trees are feathery, directional strokes, and the gate and urns have the softest edges. The foreground flowers get the crispest, thickest accents in red and yellow. Study how a high-key scene still reads clearly with so few dark notes, mostly the cypress silhouettes and shadow pockets in the flower beds. Also look at the warm-to-cool shift as the path recedes.
key decision
Chase kept the path almost as light as the sky and used it as a single horizontal leading line to the gate, saving the darkest values for the cypress and foliage masses that frame it.
recreation guide
William Merritt Chase’s *An Italian Garden* (1909) represents the culmination of his mature Impressionist landscape practice, characterized by a 'noble sense of color' and a fluent, loosely brushed style (Source 7). Chase was a prominent exponent of American Impressionism who adopted the *plein air* method, often teaching students to paint outdoors to capture the immediate effects of light and atmosphere (Source 5). His landscape work, which gained recognition in the late 1880s, was influenced by French Impressionism and focused on capturing the transient qualities of nature rather than topographical precision (Source 7). The painting likely exhibits the broad masses and confident brushwork for which Chase was known, avoiding the 'smallness' or over-modeling he advised against in his teaching (Source 4).
estimated time
20-30 hours over 5-7 sessions (allowing for drying time between glazes/scumbles if employed)
materials
4 items
steps
4 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Oil paints (Ultramarine, White, Black, plus Red and Yellow earths/ochres) | Primary pigments for underpainting and final color application | — |
| Oil of Copavia (or modern stand oil/linseed oil) | Medium for the first and second paintings to ensure fluidity and transparency | Stand oil or refined linseed oil |
| Canvas or prepared panel | Support for the oil painting | — |
| Varnish (optional, for later glazing stages) | To mix with oil for advanced glazing techniques once mastery is gained | Dammar varnish or modern painting medium |
preparation
surface prep
While specific preparation for *An Italian Garden* is not detailed, Chase’s training in Munich and his adherence to traditional craftsmanship suggest a standard oil ground. The sources emphasize the importance of the artist being a 'sound craftsman' with knowledge of their medium (Source 4). A neutral or warm-toned ground is likely appropriate to facilitate the glazing and scumbling techniques described in traditional oil painting practice (Source 3).
underdrawing
Chase’s 'loosely brushed style' (Source 7) suggests that underdrawing was likely minimal or executed directly in paint, consistent with Impressionist *plein air* practices. There is no evidence of detailed preparatory sketches for this specific work; the focus was on capturing the 'broad masses' (Source 4).
underpainting
The sources describe a traditional method involving a grisaille (monochrome underpainting) using black, ultramarine, and white, applied with oil of copavia (Source 3). This initial layer establishes the tonal values before color is introduced. Chase’s emphasis on 'broad masses' (Source 4) supports an underpainting that defines the major light and shadow structures without fine detail.
color palette
Ultramarine
Pure pigment
Underpainting and sky/shadow tones, as part of the initial monochrome layer (Source 3)
White
Pure pigment
Underpainting highlights and mixing for glazes/scumbles (Source 3)
Black
Pure pigment
Underpainting shadows and depth (Source 3)
Red and Yellow tones
Various reds and yellows (ochres, vermilion, etc.)
Glazing and scumbling over the dry grisaille to introduce local color and warmth, mimicking the 'tinting of an engraving' (Source 3)
composition
Chase’s landscapes are characterized by a coherent composition where elements are arranged to create a wide view, often including the sky as a significant element (Source 1). While specific compositional details of *An Italian Garden* are not described in the sources, Chase’s general practice involved capturing 'natural scenery' with an emphasis on light and atmosphere rather than strict topographical accuracy (Source 1, Source 7). The composition likely avoids 'smallness' and over-modeling, favoring broad, confident strokes (Source 4).
step by step
underpainting
step 01
Apply a monochrome underpainting (grisaille) using black, ultramarine, and white mixed with oil of copavia. Focus on establishing the broad masses of light and shadow, avoiding fine detail.
Tip — Ensure the underpainting is quite dry before proceeding to color layers.
Grisaille underpainting
first pass
step 02
Begin introducing color through glazing and scumbling. Apply transparent coats of red and yellow tones over the dry grisaille, similar to tinting an engraving with watercolors.
Tip — Glazing involves transparent color; scumbling involves semi-opaque color that allows the underlying painting to show through.
Glazing and Scumbling
refining
step 03
Refine the color and light effects, ensuring that the 'broad masses' are maintained. Avoid getting 'tied down to outline' or over-modeling, which Chase advised against.
Tip — Check for 'smallness' in the brushwork; keep strokes confident and broad.
Loose brushwork
finishing
step 04
Complete the painting by adjusting the balance of light and color, ensuring the 'noble sense of color' characteristic of Chase’s work is achieved.
Tip — The final effect should capture the transient light and atmosphere of the garden.
Impressionist finish
critical techniques
Glazing and Scumbling
Used to introduce color over a dry monochrome underpainting. Glazing applies transparent color, while scumbling applies semi-opaque color, allowing the underpainting to influence the final tone. This method was practiced by old masters and is recommended for achieving depth and luminosity.
Plein Air Painting
Chase adopted the *plein air* method, painting outdoors to capture the immediate effects of light and atmosphere. This approach is central to his Impressionist landscape style.
Broad Masses
Chase emphasized painting 'broad masses' rather than getting lost in small details. This technique helps avoid 'smallness' and over-modeling, resulting in a more dynamic and cohesive composition.
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
The Practice of Oil Painting↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia bio — William Merritt Chase↗
Wikipedia: Landscape painting↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
Light pours from the upper left, creating a sun-drenched garden vista where the eye is drawn first to the pale sandy path in the foreground, then directed backward through colorful flower borders toward the ornamental gate and balustrade in the middle distance. The composition is horizontally structured with the bright path acting as a strong leading line; tall cypress trees punctuate the skyline on both sides, framing a luminous blue sky with white clouds. The architectural elements—the gate, urns, and balusters—sit on a subtle rise that creates atmospheric recession despite the relatively shallow space.
value structure
The painting operates in a high-key register with pale sandy and cream values dominating the path and lower-middle zone. The darkest accents appear in the dense green trees (particularly the cypress silhouettes and foliage masses at rear left and right) and scattered shadow areas within flower beds. When you squint, you see three distinct value groups: the very light path and central ground, the medium-dark green tree masses, and the middle-value architecture and flower clusters. The sky reads as light to medium-blue, distinctly lighter than the darkest foliage but darker than the path.
observed palette and mixes
#eae1d9
Titanium white + raw sienna + touch of yellow ochre
The primary sandy path filling the foreground; also mixed into highlights on architecture and lighter flower areas
#e0ccbf
Raw sienna + titanium white + cadmium yellow light
Warmer tones in mid-ground path and in sunlit portions of stone features (urns, gate posts, balustrade)
#b2c2cd
Ultramarine blue + titanium white + touch of purple
Sky, particularly in the upper two-thirds and atmospheric haze beyond the trees
#7f977c
Viridian + ultramarine blue + cadmium yellow medium + white
Mid-tone foliage in trees and shrub masses; softer greens in the cypress and background foliage
#626051
Raw umber + ultramarine + touch of alizarin
Darkest shadows within tree masses, beneath cypress silhouettes, and deep shadow accents in flower beds
#b1a086
Raw sienna + titanium white + ultramarine
Warm mid-tones in architecture and shadow areas of the path where reflected light occurs
edges and brushwork
Chase's brushwork here is loose and impressionistic, with soft edges dominating the foliage and distant features—the cypress trees and background trees are suggested with feathery, directional strokes rather than defined contours. Flowers in the immediate foreground have slightly crisper accents in red and yellow, created with thicker, more deliberate touches, while the ornamental gate and urns maintain the softest edges, suggesting atmospheric distance. The path is rendered with smooth, horizontal dragging strokes that unify its surface and lead the eye backward.
a working sequence
Establish the sky and atmospheric foundation
Block in the entire upper half with a light blue-gray, mixing your #b2c2cd base and allowing it to shift slightly warmer and lighter near the horizon line (where the trees meet the sky). Work horizontally with loose strokes, leaving white canvas peeking through for clouds. Don't overwork—let it stay soft and airy.
Lay in the major tree masses and architectural shapes
Using darker greens (#626051 and #7f97c combined), loosely block the dense tree forms at rear left, center, and rear right. Keep these shapes soft-edged and overlapping. Simultaneously place the pale stone architectural elements—the gate, balustrade, and urns—as simple light-value rectangles and cylinders without detail. The contrast between dark foliage and light stone should establish the painting's structure immediately.
Paint the path and ground plane
Fill the entire foreground and middle-ground path with your lightest value (#eae1d9), using horizontal strokes that accelerate slightly toward the distant gate to reinforce perspective. Allow subtle warm shifts (#e0ccbf) in areas where the path meets architectural shadows. This passage should feel luminous and unified—resist the urge to add texture now.
Develop the cypress tree silhouettes
Return to the tallest, narrowest trees on both sides (especially visible right of center and at far left and right edges). Using dark mixed greens with touches of ultramarine, define their distinctive columnar forms with vertical strokes. Keep edges soft but shape-affirming. These trees are crucial anchors—they frame the garden and lead the eye upward to the sky.
Layer and enrich the foliage masses
Begin adding depth to the tree canopies by layering lighter mid-tone greens (#7f977c) over the initial dark shapes, creating a sense of rounded form and light penetration. Use broken, dabbing strokes that follow the organic contours of foliage clumps. Leave pockets of darker values showing through to suggest depth. This is where your painting shifts from flat block-in to dimensional form.
Introduce flowers as color accents
Begin placing the flower clusters visible in the immediate foreground (lower left and right edges) using notes of bright red, pink, yellow, and white. These should read as relatively small, saturated accents against the greens—don't paint individual flowers, but rather suggest clusters with dabs and short strokes. Keep most of the flower work in the immediate foreground; flowers receding toward the gate should be smaller and muted.
Refine the architectural details and light effects
Gently detail the gate, urns, and balustrade posts using warmer mid-tones (#e0ccbf and #b1a086) for sunlit faces and cooler shadows. Suggest ornamental tops on the urns with minimal marks. Ensure the stone reads as in bright sunlight by keeping values high and introducing subtle shadow accents only in crevices and undersides. Avoid overstatement—the architecture should feel distant and atmospheric.
Unify and add finishing luminosity
Step back and assess the overall light direction. Strengthen any value contrasts that read as too timid—particularly the darks in the deepest foliage pockets. Add final flower accents in the foreground clusters with fresh, opaque touches. If the path feels dull, scumble a touch of warm light (#e0ccbf) across it horizontally, catching the full sun effect. The entire painting should glow with Italian garden light.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
related guides
in this vein