
plate no. 8905
Paul Delaroche, 1824
what to study here
It shows how a restricted two-note light structure against deep, tinted darkness can carry a psychological confrontation without detailed description.
The useful lesson here is how value does the storytelling. Per the vision analysis, the picture sits on very deep greenish-brown darks, nearly black, with only two bright notes: the cardinal's red robes and lit face, and Joan's pale face and cream dress. Squint and you get three zones: deep shadow in the background and the third figure, mid-tones in the floor, and bright accents on the figures. Light comes from the left and lands on the cardinal, so he reads first; the eye then moves to Joan, smaller and paler on the right. Study how edges are handled. The cardinal's face is modeled with precise, deliberate detail, while Joan's reads fresher and less detailed. Hard edges appear only where light catches form; elsewhere they dissolve into the dark. The straw floor is suggested with scattered directional marks, not drawn straw by straw. The darks stay tinted rather than flat black, which keeps the dungeon atmospheric. Copy the value map in a small monochrome study before touching color.
key decision
Delaroche confines the brightest and warmest values to the cardinal's red robes and lit face, with Joan's pale face and dress as a secondary light, all against near-black greenish-brown shadow. This makes the viewer read authority first and vulnerability second.
recreation guide
Paul Delaroche’s *Joan d'Arc in Prison* (1824) is a quintessential example of his position as a bridge between Academicism/Neoclassicism and Romanticism. The work reflects his aim to present a 'philosophical analysis' of historical events, linking them to nineteenth-century understandings of historical truth (Source 1). While the subject matter appeals to Romantic sensibilities through its dramatic and emotional weight, the execution adheres to the 'highly finished surfaces' and 'accuracy of information' characteristic of Academic and Neoclassical trends (Source 7). Delaroche sought 'pragmatic realism,' avoiding idealized norms to depict subjects with a deglorified, human quality (Source 7). This painting, exhibited at the Salon of 1824, demonstrates his early mastery of history painting, which focuses on narrative moments rather than static portraits (Source 3).
estimated time
40-60 hours over 8-12 sessions
materials
8 items
steps
6 in sequence
materials
| item | purpose | modern equivalent |
|---|---|---|
| Oil paints | Primary medium for the final layers | — |
| Canvas | Support for the oil painting | Linen or cotton canvas, primed |
| Charcoal | Underdrawing and initial shading | Vine charcoal or compressed charcoal |
| Raw Umber | Initial painting stage and underpainting | Natural Earth Pigment (Raw Umber) |
| White pigment | Mixing with raw umber for underpainting | Titanium White or Lead White (historical) |
| Turpentine | Thinner for initial oil applications | Odorless Mineral Spirits or Gum Turpentine |
| Varnish | Medium for glazing and scumbling in later stages | Dammar Varnish or Synthetic Resin Varnish |
| Black and Ultramarine | Part of the initial monochrome/underpainting palette mentioned by Reynolds/Delaroche tradition | Ivory Black and Ultramarine Blue |
preparation
surface prep
The surface should be prepared to allow for a 'highly finished' appearance consistent with Delaroche's Academic training (Source 7). While specific ground recipes for this 1824 work are not detailed in the sources, the artist's later monumental work *The Hemicycle* utilized encaustic mixtures on plaster (Source 4), suggesting a comfort with smooth, durable surfaces. For oil on canvas, a smooth, white or neutral ground is recommended to facilitate the glazing techniques associated with his style.
underdrawing
Begin with a charcoal underdrawing. The sources advise drawing and shading in charcoal, using a dry brush to model forms before applying paint (Source 5). It is critical to make all corrections in the charcoal stage, as charcoal offers little resistance to brushwork and can be easily removed with bread, whereas correcting errors in paint is 'fatal to lucidity' (Source 5). The drawing should be slightly smaller than life if studying from a model, but for a history painting, it should be scaled to the final canvas dimensions.
underpainting
Delaroche’s practice, influenced by the academic tradition, likely involved a monochrome underpainting. Sir Joshua Reynolds, whose methods influenced the academic milieu, described a method using oil of copavia with black, ultramarine, and white for the first and second paintings (Source 8). For this recreation, use raw umber and white with turpentine to establish the tonal values (Source 5). This grisaille stage allows the artist to 'mentally extract the red and yellow colours' and focus on form and light before introducing color (Source 8).
color palette
Raw Umber
Raw Umber + Turpentine
Underpainting and establishing dark values
White
White pigment + Turpentine/Oil
Underpainting highlights and mixing with umber
Black
Black pigment
Initial monochrome layers (per Reynolds/Delaroche tradition)
Ultramarine
Ultramarine Blue
Initial monochrome layers and cool shadows
Red and Yellow tones
Transparent reds and yellows
Glazing and scumbling over the dry grisaille to add warmth and local color
composition
As a history painting, the composition should depict a specific moment in a narrative story, likely containing a number of figures to convey the 'philosophical analysis' of the event (Source 1, Source 3). Delaroche’s style emphasizes dramatic effect over strict historical truth, often prioritizing emotional impact (Source 4). The composition should avoid static portraiture in favor of a dynamic narrative scene (Source 3). Specific details of Joan d'Arc’s pose or the prison layout are not described in the provided sources, so the artist should rely on the general principle of 'monoscenic depictions of crucial moments' (Source 2).
step by step
underdrawing
step 01
Draw the composition in charcoal, focusing on accurate construction and proportions.
Tip — Compare the drawing with a mirror or reference to check scale and accuracy. Correct all errors now.
Charcoal drawing
underpainting
step 02
Apply a thin wash of raw umber and white with turpentine to establish light and shadow values.
Tip — Do not put down paint with obvious errors in construction. Use a dry brush to model forms.
Grisaille underpainting
step 03
Refine the monochrome layer using black, ultramarine, and white if following the Reynolds/Delaroche academic tradition.
Tip — Ensure the grisaille is completely dry before proceeding to color.
Monochrome modeling
first pass
step 04
Begin glazing and scumbling with oil paints, introducing red and yellow tones.
Tip — Glazing is a transparent coat; scumbling is semi-opaque. Use these to tint the underlying drawing like watercolors.
Glazing and Scumbling
refining
step 05
Build up layers to achieve the 'highly finished surface' characteristic of Delaroche’s Academic style.
Tip — Be aware of simultaneous contrast; colors will appear different depending on adjacent tones.
Layering
finishing
step 06
Final adjustments to ensure the 'pragmatic realism' and dramatic effect intended by the artist.
Tip — Avoid idealizing the subject; maintain the deglorified, human portrayal typical of Delaroche.
Detailing
critical techniques
Glazing and Scumbling
Used to apply color over a dry monochrome underpainting. Glazing adds transparent color, while scumbling adds semi-opaque texture. This method was practiced by old masters and is recommended for achieving depth and finish.
Simultaneous Contrast
The artist must account for how adjacent colors affect each other. The eye perceives colors differently based on their surroundings, so adjustments must be made to maintain color accuracy.
Pragmatic Realism
Depicting subjects without idealization, focusing on historical truth and human emotion rather than romanticized heroism.
common pitfalls
what the sources don't tell us
Where the corpus is silent, we say so rather than guess. These are the gaps a complete recreation guide would normally cover that our source passages don't.
grounded in
The technical procedure in this guide traces to the following classical art-instruction texts.
The Practice of Oil Painting — PAINTING FROM LIFE↗
The Practice of Oil Painting — COLOURING A MONOCHROME↗
Laws of Contrast of Colour↗
cross-referenced from
Named facts about this artwork and artist were checked against these reference pages.
Wikipedia bio — Paul Delaroche — part 3↗
Wikipedia: History painting — History painting — part 1↗
Wikipedia bio — Paul Delaroche — part 7↗
Read more about the corpus on the sources page and how the guides are built on the methods page.
what the eye sees
A tense interrogation unfolds in a dungeon setting: the cardinal in brilliant red robes dominates the center-left, leaning forward with piercing authority toward Joan of Arc, who sits smaller and submissive on the right in pale clothing. A shadowy third figure in dark robes stands barely visible in the background left, observing the exchange. Strong directional light from the left illuminates the cardinal's face and robes as the composition's psychological anchor, while Joan's pale face and cream dress read as the vulnerable secondary focus. The viewer's eye locks first on the cardinal's penetrating expression, then traces to Joan's fearful response, with the atmospheric darkness as a pressurizing frame.
value structure
The painting rests on dramatic high contrast: very deep, nearly black greenish-brown shadows dominate the composition, establishing a cold dungeon atmosphere. The cardinal's red robe and illuminated face form the brightest, warmest mass; Joan's pale face and dress create the secondary light note. Straw-scattered floor and the cardinal's hands anchor mid-tones. When squinted, three distinct value zones emerge: deep shadow (background and third figure), middle tones (floor and atmospheric recession), and bright accents (cardinal's features and robes, Joan's face). The value separation is intentional and psychologically charged, not subtle.
observed palette and mixes
#031106
Ultramarine blue + burnt sienna + touch of ivory black
Dominant background shadows and atmospheric gloom defining the dungeon interior
#010d04
Ivory black + ultramarine blue
Deepest recesses: the background figure's silhouette, shadow cavities, and farthest atmospheric zones
#6d592e
Raw sienna + yellow ochre + white
Straw scattered across the floor and light stone tones within the shadows
#49220f
Burnt umber + ultramarine blue + alizarin
Midtone shadow passages on the cardinal's drapery and architectural surfaces
#492c18
Alizarin crimson + ultramarine blue + burnt sienna
Deep folds within the cardinal's red robes where light doesn't reach
#361708
Burnt sienna + ivory black
Darkest anchoring shadows throughout, definition of form
#E8381F
Vermilion or cadmium red deep with touch of alizarin for spatial depth
The cardinal's vibrant vestments—the color focal point of the entire composition
#F4E4CF
Titanium white + minimal yellow ochre + touch of ultramarine for shadow
Joan's pale face and cream-white dress; the secondary light anchor
edges and brushwork
Delaroche uses romantic-era technique with soft, atmospheric handling in shadows and background creating spatial recession. The cardinal's face displays precise, deliberate brushwork rendering every aging line and feature; his red robes feature flowing folds defined by directional strokes and subtle value transitions rather than contour lines. Joan's face receives careful modeling but reads fresher and less detailed. The background is loosely washed with broken atmospheric strokes; the straw floor employs gestural, scattered marks in varied directions suggesting texture through pattern and value modulation rather than description. Hard edges appear only where light catches form sharply; elsewhere edges dissolve into atmosphere.
a working sequence
Establish composition and value framework
With dilute burnt sienna, lightly draw the three figures: cardinal forward and centered, Joan smaller on the right, the background observer as a shadowed silhouette left. Block in major value masses: very dark background and background figure, mid-tone floor, reserve brightest areas for the cardinal's face and robes and Joan's face. The composition should read as a clear triangle with psychological imbalance—the cardinal commands the space.
Atmospheric background layer
Paint the background with ultramarine blue, burnt sienna, and yellow ochre mixed to a cool, greenish-brown. Apply this loosely but firmly to establish the dungeon mood and push the background away. Keep the background figure barely distinct from this wash—just a shape in the gloom. This layer should feel cold and confining, creating atmospheric pressure around the foreground figures.
Cardinal's red vestments—color anchor
Block in the cardinal's robes with vibrant vermilion or cadmium red, keeping the color fresh in lit areas. In shadow folds, drop the value and add ultramarine to create depth without losing the red's essential nature. The robes should read as luminous fabric lit from the left; the folds should follow his seated, leaning posture. This red is your compositional anchor—get it singing.
Cardinal's face—psychological authority
Paint the cardinal's face with precise modeling using flesh tones (white + yellow ochre + touch of alizarin) for lit passages and warm shadows (burnt sienna + alizarin). Render facial features carefully: the aged lines around the eyes, the firm mouth, the penetrating gaze. The light catches his left cheekbone and forehead; shadows define his severity and age. This face must convey intellectual authority and interrogative pressure—every line should suggest judgment.
Joan of Arc—vulnerability and presence
Paint Joan's pale face with subtle, delicate modeling using very light flesh tone (white + minimal yellow ochre + touch of ultramarine for shadows). Keep her face fresh and young; the power lies in her expression—fear, resignation, or quiet suffering. Her cream-white dress should show soft folds with value shifts but no harsh lines; the fabric should wrap around her seated form naturally. The spatial relationship between her and the cardinal should feel psychologically charged.
Floor and environmental texture
Render the straw-scattered floor with broken, gestural brushwork using khaki tones (raw sienna + yellow ochre + white) with darker accents (burnt umber) indicating shadows between straw and stone. Use directional marks and value variation rather than detailed rendering of individual straws. This grounds the figures spatially and adds the tactile reality of a prison setting; it also gives your eye a place to rest between the intense faces.
Background observer refinement
Strengthen the background figure's presence while keeping it subordinate and atmospheric. Suggest dark robes emerging from shadow with just enough form indication—perhaps a hand holding a document, the edge of a hat or headwear—to read as a witness. This figure should feel present but removed, observing the interrogation from a psychological distance.
Edge control and light logic
Refine edges selectively: sharpen where light catches (the cardinal's profile line, Joan's cheekbone, hands in light), soften where forms recede into shadow. The cardinal should feel three-dimensional against the dark background through edge softness on his far side. Ensure the light direction is consistent across all three figures; shadows should fall predictably even within the gloom. The spatial logic should feel inevitable.
Final atmospheric integration
Step back and check the psychological mood: does the interrogation feel tense and inevitable? Ensure the cardinal's red remains the strongest color note without becoming garish. The values should read clearly from a distance. If needed, apply a very thin atmospheric glaze of dilute ultramarine + burnt sienna over darker areas to unify the dungeon setting. The painting should feel like a moment captured in cold, accusatory light.
where studies of this painting go wrong
measured difficulty
tips & new artworks in your inbox
no spam — unsubscribe anytime.
or to save artworks, chat, and track progress
in this vein

Romantic Landscape
Karl Lessing

Self-portrait with his brother Francesco
Giuseppe Tominz

Oenone Refuse de Secourir Pâris au Siège de Troie
Léon Cogniet

Duke of Alba
Francisco Goya

Blick Aus Dem Wald Ins Tal
Andreas Achenbach

Young Girl Fixing Her Hair
Sophie Gengembre Anderson

The Plough Inn
William Shayer

Hudson River Landscape
Johann Hermann Carmiencke